The Windup: A show about Baseball · The Athletic
The Roundtable | Players who have made a HOF push this season
September 19, 2025·45 min·4 clips
Sam Miller reveals how a player's Hall of Fame chances can flip from unlikely to likely in just one season.
As heard by us
A smart, loose Hall of Fame debate that keeps circling back to baseball.
This episode turns a Hall of Fame question into a baseball argument about which pitchers can keep building a case after 30. Grant Brisby and Sam Miller keep the tone skeptical without letting it turn flat, and the Kevin Gausman discussion gives the whole thing a steady center.
Why you'd press play
When you want a loose Hall of Fame argument that still does the homework.
Listen to the show on