The Windup: A show about Baseball · The Athletic

The Roundtable | BONUS EPISODE-Jane Leavy talks about her new book

September 9, 2025·54 min·4 clips
Jane Leavy explains why the Yankees' $350 million roster fails to address fundamental flaws like lacking a third baseman.
In this bonus episode of The Roundtable, host Andy McCullough interviews legendary author Jane Leavy about her new book, 'Make Me Commissioner,' which critiques modern baseball's issues. They discuss analytics' impact on the game, pitching injuries, rule changes like the pitch clock, and how these factors affect fan engagement and the sport's narrative appeal.

As heard by us

A loose baseball conversation that keeps returning to what the sport gets wrong.

Jane Levy and Andy McCullough spend their time on Make Me Commissioner moving from Betty the dog and a wasp sting to a Cape League story, then into a wider argument about how baseball is played, judged, and debated by the people who care most about it.

Read the full review in PlayNext →

Why you'd press play

You want a baseball chat that starts with a dog at the vet and ends up arguing how the game should be judged.

Read the full recommendation in PlayNext →
Listen to the show on