The Welsh Rugby Podcast · Reach Podcasts

Wales squad reaction: Carre in from the cold

·28 min·2 clips
Rhys Carre is back in the Wales squad after being bombed out for the World Cup, sparking debate over the 25-cap rule.
Ben James opens at the Vale Resort as Wales announce Steve Tandy’s first squad. Alex Bywater and James quickly land on Rhys Carey’s return, treating it as the headline because it is both unexpected and telling about Wales’s current options. The special dispensation from the Welsh Rugby Union professional rugby board is part of that story. They note that Carey’s availability opens a selection debate that reaches far beyond one prop, because Wales are short in a few areas and the squad has to balance what is needed now against what might still shift before Argentina. The discussion keeps coming back to whether Carey should start. One view is that the case is strong enough to put him in immediately, while the other keeps pointing out that injuries over the next couple of weeks could still change everything. Max Llewellyn’s slight summer injury becomes a key hinge in that midfield debate. Ben Thomas and Llewellyn are treated as the likely centre pairing for the last five tests under Matt Sherratt, which makes the present uncertainty feel less dramatic than it first sounds. Johnny Williams is absent. Joe Roberts is absent too, and the conversation reads those omissions as part of Scarlets’ poor start rather than isolated calls. Max Page misses out after not winning a cap in the summer. There is also no Ellis Mee in the back three. Up front, Ross Moriarty’s omission raises eyebrows. The show does not leave those names hanging, because every absence becomes another clue about depth, form, and how little room Wales still have. Will Rowlands’ retirement then broadens the frame. His 41 caps, five-year test career, late debut, quick rise, and 2022 recognition are all measured against the demands of club and international rugby. The hosts sound especially reflective about what he gave Wales at the 2023 World Cup and in the year before it. There is clear admiration for his quality, but also a blunt sense that Wales needed him to stand up more in the difficult stretch after the World Cup. The conversation closes by widening into the bigger question of who in a younger squad might stand up to the union in the same way that older, more established players once did. It ends with the sense that this first Tandy squad has already produced several reporting angles, and that the autumn will only bring more.

As heard by us

Steve Tandy's first Wales squad is unpacked through Carey's return, the key omissions, and the wider selection questions it raises.

Steve Tandy's first Wales squad sits at the center of the discussion, with Rhys Carey back in the frame after the World Cup controversy and the WRU professional rugby board granting special dispensation for him to play.

Read the full review in PlayNext →

Why you'd press play

You want the first serious read on Steve Tandy's opening Wales squad.

Read the full recommendation in PlayNext →
Listen to the show on