The Truman Charities Podcast · Jamie Truman

Can Women Have It All OR Can They Have It All Just Not All At Once? | Best-Selling Author Erica Komisar "Being There: Why Prioritizing Motherhood In The First Three Years Matters" Ep. 121

·44 min·4 clips

Jamie Truman explores if women can have it all with Erica Komazar, delving into attachment disorders and early childhood impacts.

This episode of The Truman Charities Podcast features host Jamie Truman interviewing Erica Komisar, a social worker, psychoanalyst, and author of "Being There: Why Prioritizing Motherhood in the First Three Years Matters." They explore the central question of whether women can "have it all" or if they must sequence career and motherhood. Komisar's professional background in a Brooklyn clinic informs her perspective on early childhood development. The conversation examines how attachment disorders can transmit across generations. A key topic is the significance of the primary caretaker during a child's first three years, despite the child's lack of conscious memory. The discussion covers the impact on a baby's cortisol levels and its long-term effects on the child's future. Komisar addresses what it means to be psychologically "present" with a child and evaluates the best alternative care options when a mother cannot be there. She offers advice for mothers who regret not being more present during those early years. The episode analyzes the distinct and equally important roles of mothers and fathers. Komisar argues that young women should consider how their career choices will align with future motherhood, a conversation she feels is often missing. A surprising claim is that the mother's physical and emotional presence is uniquely critical for regulating an infant's stress biology. The interview suggests that societal pressures often minimize the biological and psychological necessities of early maternal care. Komisar's insights challenge the common narrative that high-quality alternative care can fully substitute for a mother's presence in the earliest years. The tone is conversational and educational, blending personal anecdote with professional expertise. It is styled as a thoughtful dialogue between the host and an author advocating for a specific parenting philosophy. This episode would deeply resonate with parents, especially mothers, and individuals interested in child psychology and work-life balance debates. Listeners skeptical of traditional gender roles or who prefer evidence-based critiques of attachment theory might find the perspectives presented less compelling.

Listen to the show on

Apple Podcasts Spotify

Play clips from this episode More from The Truman Charities Podcast