The Trial Of Karen Read | Justice For John O'Keefe · True Crime Today

MA v. Karen Read Murder Retrial - Day 30 Part 3

·1 hr 9 min·5 clips
An audit exposed 1,500 bodies left unattended under Dr. LaPasada's leadership as chief medical examiner.
The witness is asked to explain what the defense is trying to introduce. Counsel says direct examination already highlighted Dr. LaPasada's credentials and office successes. The proposed audit is from 2005 and comes from the Rhode Island Department of Health. It says there were no reports, incomplete reports, and unsigned reports for over 1,500 individuals between June 30, 2000 and June 30, 2005. Counsel treats that backlog as negligence, if not malfeasance. The audit also recommended changes to the standards, policies, and practices of the office. The discussion then turns to another expert, Dr. Rentschler. Slide 55 draws objections because counsel says parts of it are opinions that bolster either the witness or someone else's work. Slide 56 is only partly accepted, with objections to the parts that repeat self-endorsement. Slide 58 is challenged on the ground that a witness should not comment on another expert's report in a PowerPoint. Slide 66 is treated as an inadmissible opinion about what the jury should conclude from the Commonwealth's evidence. Slide 67 is narrower. Counsel says the witness could testify that he has not seen any simulation by Dr. Welcher, but presenting it in a way that suggests doubt is not appropriate. Slide 68 raises hearsay concerns because only a random page from Dr. Welcher's report is being offered. The objection is that one page takes the report out of context. The questioning then moves to body temperature and injury mechanics. Counsel returns to Mr. O'Keefe's injuries and the claim that they are inconsistent with being hit by the back of the SUV, including the spoiler and the bumper. The segment closes with the courtroom video cue and a note that more live coverage is coming up.

As heard by us

A dense courtroom hour built around objections, expert foundations, and contested records.

This episode stays in the weeds of courtroom proof. It centers on the defense's presentation of Dr. LaPasada's credentials, a 2005 Rhode Island Department of Health audit, and objections over slides, expert opinion, and hearsay. The focus is narrow on purpose.

Read the full review in PlayNext →

Why you'd press play

If you want the evidence fight, not the recap, start here.

Read the full recommendation in PlayNext →
Listen to the show on