The Trial Of Karen Read | Justice For John O'Keefe · True Crime Today

MA v. Karen Read Murder Retrial - Day 29 Part 3

·1 hr 23 min·5 clips
Dr. Lappasadar states she reached a definite scientific conclusion about whether John O'Keefe's arm injuries were from a dog bite.
The hour stays with Dr. La Posada. The Commonwealth says her resume, report, and prior testimony do not show the specific training, study, or methodology needed to call Mr. O'Keefe's wounds dog bites. The objection stays narrow. On accident reconstruction, the same point comes up: she is not an accident reconstructionist, and the materials she reviewed are said to be only part of the record. That is the frame. The Commonwealth says there is nothing on the CV, in the report, or in direct examination that shows experience breaking glass or plastics, or linking wound causation to a broken taillight. The reach matters. Counsel also argues that the proposed opinion would move beyond the arm wounds and into a broader conclusion that Mr. O'Keefe was not involved in a collision, which they call improper without a basis. Defense pushes back. It responds that a federal court in another case qualified Dr. La Posada as an expert, and treats that ruling as a meaningful credential rather than a small footnote. The federal qualification is central. From the defense side, she was not involved in these cases, and her background should not be reduced to the Commonwealth's description alone. The exchange keeps tightening. Each side returns to the same questions: what she knows, how she knows it, and whether that knowledge is enough to support the opinions sought here. Nothing broader is added. The testimony moves through credentials, objections, and replies instead of scene-setting or recap. The courtroom rhythm is exact. The pressure comes from sequence: establish the expert, define the method, test the foundation, and then see what opinion survives. The result is procedural. It becomes a close look at how expert language can turn on the limits of method rather than on sweeping argument.

As heard by us

A procedural hour about expert foundation, credentials, and the limits of courtroom opinion.

The hour stays locked on one narrow question: whether Dr. La Posada has enough grounding to speak on dog bites and accident reconstruction. The back-and-forth keeps circling her credentials, her CV, her report, and what she actually studied or used in this line of work.

Read the full review in PlayNext →

Why you'd press play

If you want the expert-qualification fight before the ruling, press play.

Read the full recommendation in PlayNext →
Listen to the show on