The Trial Of Karen Read | Justice For John O'Keefe · True Crime Today

MA v. Karen Read Murder Retrial - Day 29 Part 1

·1 hr 29 min·5 clips
The defense claims the prosecution waited years to call rebuttal witnesses on dog bite evidence.
The morning opens with live courtroom coverage from the Karen Reed trial. Counsel takes up a motion to limit Dr. Rentschler, but says it is not ready for argument yet and will be dealt with later. The court then turns to the Commonwealth's motion to call rebuttal witnesses. Defense counsel argues that Dr. Crosby and Ms. Boone should not be used in rebuttal because the defendant's dog-bite theory has been known for years and was already presented at the first trial. The timing is challenged as improper, since the Commonwealth has been on notice from the start of the case. The judge then brings the jurors back and asks the standard questions about following instructions, avoiding outside research, and not encountering news about the case. Dr. Wolfe is called back. A photograph from a 29 mile per hour impact test is shown and identified. The witness says it is a true and accurate photograph of the dummy after the crash test. Counsel asks what the photo shows, and the witness identifies the dummy as Rescue Randy. The questioning turns to which arm is visible and how the dummy was positioned at impact. The witness says the left arm is shown and that the right side of the dummy would have been contacted by the vehicle. Counsel then shifts to the damage in the clothing. The witness explains that the defects in the sweatshirt came from the dummy sliding on the pavement to its final resting position. The testimony stays technical and slow, step by step. The questioning then moves to tests A and B. Counsel confirms that the smaller dummy was five foot nine. The witness is asked about the sweatshirt sizes used in the tests. A new sweatshirt similar to John O'Keefe's was bought in extra large, and a second one in medium. Counsel presses on whether the extra large was actually used. The witness says he does not recall the exact sizes offhand. The exchange keeps circling back to what was used, why it was used, and how closely the test matched the real-world size of the person being discussed. The court then moves toward displaying a picture from test A to refresh the witness's memory. The segment ends with the reconstruction still under scrutiny.

As heard by us

A procedural retrial hour built around rebuttal motions, crash-test testimony, and cross-examination pressure.

Day 29 Part 1 keeps its focus on the Karen Read retrial's mechanics: the rebuttal dispute over Dr. Crosby and Ms. Boone, a quick reset with jurors, and then testimony about a crash-test dummy, a sweatshirt, and what the damage may show the court.

Read the full review in PlayNext →

Why you'd press play

Press play if you want the courtroom argument before the next witness takes the stand.

Read the full recommendation in PlayNext →
Listen to the show on