The Trail Went Cold

The Trail Went Cold - Episode 477 - Bill & Peggy Stephenson, Bill & Kay Wood

·55 min·5 clips
In 2011, Bill and Peggy Stevenson were found murdered in their condo, with the killer staging the scene for hours to send an unknown message.
For starters, Bill and Peggy Stevenson are found murdered in their Florence, Kentucky condo after missing morning church service. Both are 74. Their deaths are ruled blunt force trauma and sharp force trauma. Few details about the crime scene are released to the public. The bodies and a number of items in the condo are moved around and staged in a specific fashion to send some sort of message. The staging is treated as an attempt to signal something about the crime. Investigators believe the killer remained at the scene for hours after the murders. An unidentified DNA profile is found there. It has never matched anyone. The case remains unsolved. The episode then places that killing beside the 2011 murder of Bill Wood and the disappearance of his wife, Kay Wood. Those crimes took place in different states. They happened only two months apart. There does not appear to be any connection between the two cases. The Stevenson murders get the deeper treatment. Detective Cox keeps returning to the idea that both Bill and Peggy had to die. If the offender only had a problem with one of them, there were apparently chances to strike when they were alone. Some valuable items, including cash, were left behind in the open. That makes robbery look unlikely. Bill's trucker's chapel and his spiritual services to long-haul truck drivers are part of the surrounding context. The secluded part of the condo complex also helps explain why nobody reported anything unusual.

As heard by us

A staged condo murder and a second unresolved case keep the mystery locked in place.

The Trail Went Cold frames two 2011 cold cases around elderly married couples, and it does so with a measured eye for crimes that leave behind more staging than answer.

Read the full review in PlayNext →

Why you'd press play

Play this when you want two cold cases, one brutal condo scene, and no fake sense of closure.

Read the full recommendation in PlayNext →
Listen to the show on