Edition Wars Christmas 2024 Day 6: 2024 DMG Chapter 3 part 3 (Edition Wars 131)

·1 hr 6 min·5 clips

Sam Dillon joins to dissect the 2024 DMG's approach to NPCs, where everything non-player is a monster.

The episode is part of a holiday series analyzing the 2024 Dungeon Master's Guide, specifically Chapter 3. Host Sam Dillon joins to review various sections, starting with NPC design, where they note that in this edition, all non-player entities are classified as monsters. They discuss the six elements for NPCs: name, alignment, appearance, stat block, personality, and secret, critiquing the lack of fields for motivation and faction affiliation in the NPC tracker form. The hosts praise the name tables for being organized by tone rather than race, enhancing setting themes. Moving to poisons, they examine entries like purple worm poison and midnight tears, highlighting story potential but noting inconsistent save DCs. The renown system is analyzed for its underuse in published adventures, with suggestions to integrate it with character backgrounds. Settlements are covered, with nostalgia for removed random building tables but acceptance of the new tracker form. Siege equipment, such as lightning cannons and keg launchers, is criticized for poor scaling and action economy. Supernatural gifts like blessings and charms are praised as alternate rewards, though more narrative integration is desired. Traps are reviewed with standard examples, but the design table is faulted for static attack bonuses. Throughout, the hosts balance critiques with acknowledgment of the chapter's usefulness for new and experienced DMs, emphasizing optional rules and modding potential.

As heard by us

A practical edition comparison on NPCs, retainers, and the rules that make table-side characters usable.

The Tome Show treats the 2024 DMG's NPC guidance as something to be tested at the table, not just read as design text. Its best stretch comes in the discussion of the six NPC elements, the line between ordinary NPCs and retainers, and what changes when a retainer starts to…

Read the full review in PlayNext →

Why you'd press play

You get a close look at how the 2024 DMG frames NPCs around the party, then a quick, wry detour into poison rules and older-edition lookup habits.

Read the full recommendation in PlayNext →

Listen to the show on

Apple Podcasts Spotify

Play clips from this episode More from The Tome Show