The Tax Sale Podcast - Investing in Tax Deeds & Tax Liens · Casey Denman

E408: Why OTC Tax Sale Deals Fail (+ What Actually Works)

·15 min·1 clip
Casey Dimm identifies the single biggest OTC investing mistake: buying cheap properties without any exit strategy.
Casey Dimm opens by pushing back on the idea that OTC tax-sale investing is easy money. He says he has seen plenty of people make good money with OTC investments, but he has also watched a lot of investors waste time chasing the wrong ones. The episode keeps circling that gap. OTC stands for over-the-counter, and he defines it as property that went through a tax foreclosure, made it to a tax sale auction, and did not receive a bid. In some places, OTC means true over-the-counter: you walk in, buy, and leave. In others, it is an offer-and-approval process or a kind of re-auction. The point is simple. The label changes from place to place, but the leftover-property problem stays the same. Casey keeps coming back to the idea that OTC is not a casual strategy. He says that if you are too tight on your process, you are usually gambling, not investing. He warns that quality properties rarely slip through the cracks waiting for a beginner to scoop them up. That assumption, he says, is what traps people. He also makes it clear that OTC does not work the same in every state. Some counties offer true over-the-counter deals. Some do not. Some states make the process slow enough that a buyer needs a system instead of a hunch. He recommends having buyers in mind before you buy. He recommends knowing your exit before you chase the deal. He then turns to what does work. One example is buying multiple lots and selling them as a bundle. A single junk lot can be hard to move, but a package can be easier to market. Another example is campsite or off-grid lots. He points out that these are often too small or too limited for normal building, which changes how they need to be evaluated. The strategy is not about hoping for a miracle. It is about understanding what the property can realistically be used for. Casey keeps the same caution throughout. He treats resale consequences, zoning limits, setbacks, minimum square footage requirements, and buyer demand as part of the actual math. The episode closes on the idea that successful OTC investors do not just find deals. They create their own opportunities. That is the version of the strategy he sees as genuinely profitable.

As heard by us

A blunt guide to OTC deals that keeps investors from mistaking leftovers for easy money.

OTC tax-sale deals can sound like a shortcut, but Casey Dimm keeps pulling the idea back to basics. Leftover properties are not automatic bargains, and the rules change from state to state.

Read the full review in PlayNext →

Why you'd press play

Learn why OTC deals fail before you chase the wrong leftover property.

Read the full recommendation in PlayNext →
Listen to the show on