The Talking Dead #692: Rewatch – Season 3 episode 1 & 2

·1 hr 24 min·5 clips

In the prison tunnels, Hershel gets bitten, leading to a gruesome, multi-chop leg amputation by Rick just as new prisoners appear.

The episode opens with hosts Chris and Jason noting the date and briefly discussing holiday plans before introducing the main topic: a rewatch of The Walking Dead Season 3, episodes 1 and 2. They begin by reading a detailed listener email from Matthew in London, who criticizes the second season of the Daryl Dixon spinoff for implausible writing and a lack of character development compared to the original series. Chris and Jason engage with this critique, discussing pacing issues in modern TV. The rewatch analysis starts with 'Seed'. They highlight the cold open, where the group raids a house, showcasing their improved skills after eight months of wandering. They discuss details like Carl almost eating dog food, the group's encounter with riot-gear zombies, and the discovery of the prison. A significant portion covers the growing tension between Rick and Lori, and the introduction of Michonne. The climax of 'Seed' is analyzed in depth: the group enters the prison tunnels, gets separated, and Hershel is bitten by a lurker. Rick performs a frantic, multi-chop amputation of Hershel's leg just as a group of prisoners, including Axel, discovers them. The discussion of 'Sick' picks up immediately from that cliffhanger. They cover Rick's handling of the medical emergency and the tense standoff with the prisoners. The deal to clear a cell block is made, leading to the death of Big Tiny and Rick's execution of Tomas with a machete. They also touch on Carol practicing a C-section on a zombie and the strained Rick-Lori relationship scene. The episode concludes with the hosts reading several 'listener reflection' emails. Debbie from Alameda shares how she discovered the podcast, and Chris from the UK sends an emotional note about how the show accompanied him through personal trials like infertility and adoption. Jamin from Pittsburgh explains his late start to watching The Walking Dead due to an aversion to popular media.

As heard by us

Holiday chatter, spiders, and a helmet lesson shape this rewatch.

The episode starts in a loose, holiday-adjacent groove, with a Christmas gift still unsettled, a birthday fallback in view, and a long spider detour before it settles back into The Walking Dead.

Read the full review in PlayNext →

Why you'd press play

You get holiday chatter, spider talk, and a very obvious helmet problem.

Read the full recommendation in PlayNext →

Listen to the show on

Apple Podcasts Spotify

Play clips from this episode More from The Talking Dead