Blue Mesa Stories (Calls from the Tipline)

January 2, 2020·21 min·2 clips

When she realizes her rescuer knows she's figured out his secret, a deadly game of cat and mouse begins.

This episode of The Subjective Truth features two caller stories connected to the show's ongoing Blue Mesa Hotel mythology. The first caller describes a late-night breakdown on an isolated highway when her car wheel completely detached. A helpful stranger in a blue minivan offered assistance, but instead of taking her to the nearby convenience store, he drove past it claiming to know a better place. The caller noticed the van was filled with Gary's Big Game wrappers, connecting the driver to the show's conspiracy about organic food replacements. Her skin crawled as she realized the implications, and she prepared to jump from the moving vehicle. Fortunately, another motorist had hit a deer ahead, forcing the van to stop completely. She escaped and ran, hearing the Gary call out to the new motorist with the same helpful greeting. The second caller, Claire from Southern California, shares her 1993 experience at Blue Mesa Hotel. As a rock enthusiast and crystal collector, she went hiking in the local terrain and discovered what appeared to be a perfect geometric cube made of yellow material. The rock had sharp corners and right angles that seemed too perfect to be natural, leading her to wonder if she had discovered something new to science. Back at the hotel in the ghost companion room, she took a bath in one of the large vintage tubs. When she emerged from the water, her hair began falling out in clumps until she was completely bald, losing even her eyebrows and all body hair. Terrified that the mysterious rock was radioactive, she rushed to the hospital. However, doctors diagnosed her with alopecia, an autoimmune disease common in her father's family that she was unaware of due to his absence from her life. The rock turned out to be ordinary pyrite, common in the area's former mining operations. Both stories follow the show's pattern of blending supernatural fears with rational explanations, though the timing and circumstances remain unsettling. The Gary encounter reinforces the show's mythology about dangerous individuals connected to the organic food conspiracy, while the Blue Mesa story adds to the hotel's reputation as a place where strange things happen, even when they have mundane causes.

Listen to the show on

Apple Podcasts Spotify

Play clips from this episode More from The Subjective Truth