The Stack Pack: An Unsolved Mysteries Podcast · The Stack Pack

Netflix Vol 3 Ep 4 - Death in a Vegas Motel

·47 min·3 clips

Buffalo Jim said his worst fear was drugs and girls in a hotel room, and he later died under that exact suspicion.

The Stack Pack opens the case like it is already half in the bar. David Howell, Mr. Rogue Dan, and Staten Island Stan start by messing with each other about names and drinks, including a 24-ounce White Claw bought at a gas station, which is exactly the kind of unnecessary detail this show treats like sacred lore. The case turns on timing. A key swipe shows up seven minutes before the room was booked, and the panel keeps circling the idea that the key-card computer may simply have been set to the wrong time while the cameras told a different story. That sounds plain until it stops being plain. If the clock was off, the mystery loses some smoke, but if someone led the man into the room first, the whole thing gets darker and a lot more believable. They never settle on one answer. Instead, they move back and forth between human error, hidden access, and the idea that the scene may have been arranged to read like drugs and girls from the start. The room gets weird fast. The hosts point out that he had a Coke problem in his early twenties, but they push back on the lazy version of that story and keep saying an old habit is not the same thing as a clean explanation for what happened here. Lisa stays in the air too. The conversation keeps reminding itself that she still matters, even when the panel drifts into side jokes and half-finished theories. The banter never really stops. There are interruptions, corrections, movie references, and a Knock Knock riff that turns into a whole side tunnel about people showing up where they should not. It gets sillier without losing the case. The tone can swing from real suspicion to crude absurdity in a couple of lines, which fits a group that sounds like it is recapping the episode while still trying to understand why the thing feels so unsettling. The ending keeps drifting. The hosts veer into X-Files jokes, Lone Gunmen nonsense, and other oddball TV detours before finally winding down and thanking everybody for listening. The mystery stays open. By the finish, the episode has not solved the case, but it has sharpened the feeling that the strangest part may be how easily a bad timeline can hide inside an even uglier story.

As heard by us

A motel mystery where timing, access, and bad theater keep colliding.

Death in a Vegas Motel hangs on a detail that can look minor until it starts pulling the whole case apart: key-swipe timing, room access, and the ugly possibility that a death scene was staged to look like drugs and girls.

Read the full review in PlayNext →

Why you'd press play

You want a mystery hang with a shaky key-swipe timeline and a loud, funny panel.

Read the full recommendation in PlayNext →

Listen to the show on

Apple Podcasts Spotify

Play clips from this episode More from The Stack Pack: An Unsolved Mysteries Podcast