The Stack Pack: An Unsolved Mysteries Podcast · The Stack Pack

Netflix Vol 3 Ep 3 - Body in Bags

·37 min·2 clips

David Carter is found in multiple bags on I-75, including a sleeping bag and a black duffel bag.

The Stack Pack opens on the body-in-bags case. The table moves straight to David Carter and Tamara Williams. The first bag is found when ODOT mowing the highway exposes a blue sleeping bag wrapped in duct tape. That discovery lands like trash, until it very clearly is not trash. The hosts keep asking how someone gets this brazen. The police shift quickly from odd find to suspected foul play. The case becomes a missing-person investigation almost immediately. A second bag raises the temperature again. Tamara keeps denying that she has seen David since Sunday. Her denial does not calm anyone down. The panel treats it as the kind of answer that sounds worse the longer it hangs there. David is described as a good dad and a small business owner. His father sees bullet holes and recognizes a crime scene from military experience. He sends everyone away. That moment matters. The hosts talk through how the police agree and treat the scene as foul play. The family reaction carries a lot of weight. There is anger in the room. There is also sadness, because the story is not just about the evidence but about what people have to live through while the facts settle in. The show keeps moving with jokes and side references. Emilio Estevez shows up as a comparison. So does the kind of movie memory that arrives out of nowhere and then refuses to leave. The riffing is loose. It turns what could have been a plain recap into a live group reaction. The panel keeps circling the same core image: a man gone, two bags, and a suspect still on the run. By the end, the episode lands on the old true-crime warning that somebody knows the truth. It leaves that thought hanging right where this case wants it.

As heard by us

A brazen true-crime case, carried by fast banter and sharp disbelief.

The Stack Pack follows the murder of David Carter and the search for Tamara Williams, opening with a blue sleeping bag found on an Ohio highway and settling into a steady current of disbelief.

Read the full review in PlayNext →

Why you'd press play

A two-bag murder case with fast banter, disbelief, and wild detours through movie riffs and side chatter.

Read the full recommendation in PlayNext →

Listen to the show on

Apple Podcasts Spotify

Play clips from this episode More from The Stack Pack: An Unsolved Mysteries Podcast