The SoCap Improv Comedy Podcast · Ralph MacLeod

Dissonance in Comedy

·20 min·2 clips

Ralph describes the improv technique of having a character react with excitement, not anger, upon discovering their spouse's infidelity.

Ralph opens with a familiar welcome. He reminds listeners that he owns and runs the Socap Improv Comedy Theater in Toronto, Ontario, Canada, at 154 Danforth Avenue above the Black Swan Tavern, where the space hosts improv classes, shows, stand-up, sketch work, rentals, and corporate events through Yes Unlimited. He frames the podcast around improv for stage and for regular life. The topic is dissonance in comedy. He defines dissonance as things that don't quite go together. He links that to cognitive dissonance, the uncomfortable feeling that comes from holding contradictory information at once, and uses a gum-wrapper example to make it concrete. Then he turns to the comic version. The core move is to give the audience one expectation, then reveal a different reality after they have leaned in and waited for the reason. He says the laugh comes when the dissonance is resolved. He uses a scenario where somebody looks excited, the crowd expects one cause, and the actual reason turns out to be relief from having had a long affair. He keeps stressing that the trick is in the mismatch. It works because the listener or audience fills in the obvious answer first and then has to adjust when the truth lands. Ralph says he likes using the same move in real life. In conversation, a surprising line can create the same effect as a stage beat, because people are already watching for the expected response. He gives his classroom example. He tells students to call him a jerk, then smiles and says they're not wrong, which turns the insult into the joke. He also points out that dissonance shows up at the start of a scene. The audience wants to know what is happening, and that suspense makes them pay attention in the same way a person does when someone starts talking to them. By the end, he returns to the feeling of recognition, where the audience feels smart for spotting how the mismatch was set up and then released. He closes with the show's loose, playful drift, including a forgotten sponsor bit and a string of fake sponsor names before a silly tongue-twister sendoff about Judge Dame Judy Dench.

As heard by us

A patient lesson in how surprise becomes a laugh.

Dissonance in Comedy treats the gap between expectation and reality as something worth sitting with, not just something to punch up for effect. Ralph McLeod keeps returning to that mismatch with plain examples, which makes the idea feel usable instead of theoretical.

Read the full review in PlayNext →

Why you'd press play

You want a clear explanation of how dissonance and expectation turn a setup into a laugh, plainly.

Read the full recommendation in PlayNext →

Listen to the show on

Apple Podcasts Spotify

Play clips from this episode More from The SoCap Improv Comedy Podcast