The Smart Real Estate Coach Podcast|Real Estate Investing · Chris Prefontaine

Episode 538: The Right Way to Insure Rental Properties, Creative Deals, and Vacancies with Seth Markum

December 17, 2025·19 min·1 clip
Seth Markum reveals why using homeowners insurance for rental properties is a costly error that could leave you unprotected.
Chris Pree frames the conversation as a year end regrouping for investors. He says the show has used NREIG for about 12 years, and Seth Markham joins from NREIG. Chris describes the company as one of the largest non owner occupied insurers. The conversation centers on making rental property insurance easier to manage. They start with buy and hold properties and move into creative deals. Chris says that matters for investors who hold title in their own name. Seth explains that the company can work with non performing notes and understands subject to deals. Chris says subject to does not have to be a headache. Seth agrees that the risk is real and the right agent matters, especially compared with a corner agent who may not understand the structure. Monthly reporting comes up as a key feature. Seth says reporting to the carrier each month adds flexibility and can make it easier to add properties without a new contract. Chris highlights that there is no down payment or fresh contract for each addition. Seth says the single policy form contemplates all phases of occupancy. The goal is to keep coverage workable as a property changes occupancy. The episode closes with the show’s usual resource and subscribe reminders.

As heard by us

A practical insurance episode for investors managing changing rental and creative-finance properties.

Chris Pree and Seth Markham from NREIG keep the focus on insurance for non-owner-occupied properties, and the conversation stays grounded in practical use.

Read the full review in PlayNext →

Why you'd press play

You need coverage that keeps up with creative deals and occupancy changes.

Read the full recommendation in PlayNext →
Listen to the show on