The Show Fantasy Baseball Podcast · Eric Charlton

17.12 - Trade Deadline Hot Stove

July 6, 2023·38 min·3 clips

Max accuses Ben of getting two top fantasy arms for nothing, sparking a league-wide controversy.

This episode of The Show Fantasy Baseball Podcast focuses on the league's first major trade of the 2023 season and the impending trade deadline. Host Jared Fabian is joined by league managers Benjamin Zwerchowski and Max Zimmerman to analyze the deal and its implications. Fabian notes this is his final recording before the birth of his child, adding a personal milestone to the league's drama. The controversial trade sends pitchers Jesús Luzardo and Pablo López from manager Hoff to Ben Zwerchowski in exchange for a future fifth-round draft pick. Max Zimmerman argues the compensation is insufficient for two top-tier arms, citing their rankings as the 18th and 36th pitchers on the Player Rater. Ben Zwerchowski defends the trade's fairness by comparing it to a prior deal where Luis Castillo and Zac Gallen were traded for a sixth and an eleventh-round pick. He uses a detailed statistical breakdown, calculating the combined innings from both pitchers equates to a full season of a high-end starter historically drafted in the fifth round. Zimmerman counters that past trades, like one involving Liam Hendriks alongside Castillo and Gallen, included better returning player compensation. The hosts reference league rule 6.02, explaining that three managers vetoed the trade, triggering a league-wide vote among the seven non-involved managers to approve or reject it. Fabian recalls a similar veto process from the previous year involving a trade for Kyle Tucker. Zwerchowski states his motivation is to win his first championship and has no current plans to keep either acquired pitcher long-term. The conversation shifts to trade etiquette, with Fabian expressing frustration over receiving unsolicited, lopsided trade offers without prior negotiation. Zimmerman admits he often fires off trade offers as conversation starters, while Zwerchowski suggests managers can be overly attached to underperforming keepers. The group identifies potential buyers and sellers as the July 13th deadline approaches, noting the standings are exceptionally tight. Zimmerman names himself and others as likely buyers, while Zwerchowski suggests managers like "Red Leg Nation" and "Campania" should consider selling to improve their futures. They reflect on last season's active deadline, which featured 14 trades, eight involving future draft picks. The tone is conversational, competitive, and filled with inside jokes and league-specific banter. This episode is ideal for fantasy baseball enthusiasts who enjoy deep dives into league politics, trade analysis, and manager strategy. Listeners unfamiliar with this specific league's history or who prefer broader baseball analysis might find the detailed, insider focus less engaging.

As heard by us

A lively fantasy baseball trade debate that feels like a real league-room argument.

Fantasy baseball talk drives this episode, with the hosts hashing out a first regular-season trade and the awkward question of what fair even looks like when both sides want to feel good about it.

Read the full review in PlayNext →

Why you'd press play

You want a first-trade fantasy baseball debate that feels like a real league chat.

Read the full recommendation in PlayNext →

Listen to the show on

Apple Podcasts Spotify

Play clips from this episode More from The Show Fantasy Baseball Podcast