James Alexander of The Bar-Kays Part 1

February 9, 2026·1 hr 30 min·7 clips

Questlove welcomes James Alexander of the Bar-Kays to explore the untold stories of Memphis music and the creation of 'Soul Finger'.

1. The Questlove Show hosts James Alexander, bassist and leader of the Bar-Kays, for a career retrospective during Black History Month. 2. Questlove introduces Alexander as a Memphis music delegate whose six decades of work—from Stax Records to worldwide tours with Isaac Hayes—is underrepresented in music history discourse. 3. The episode's central thread is how Soul Finger was created and how the Bar-Kays came to exist, framed as a series of accidents: wrong instrument, absent bassist, overheard audition. 4. Alexander first heard live music at Handy Park on Beale Street, age six or seven, when his mother took him to see B.B. King and Bobby Blue Bland performing on two flatbed trucks pushed together as a stage. 5. He entered music through the school marching band, starting on tuba because the drum section was full; he walked the instrument home on foot because its bell was too wide for the bus, with kids throwing paper into the barrel. 6. As one of two Black students sent from West Tennessee to study at the Belmont/Peabody School of Music in Nashville, he mastered tuba before a teacher gifted him a German-made upright bass—now worth approximately $8,000—that her son had abandoned. 7. His brother pawned that upright bass to fund a dog-track gambling addiction, selling it at a Memphis pawn shop for around $700; Alexander nearly committed violence but instead cried; his father secretly put a Harmony bass and amplifier on layaway at the same shop for under $200 and revealed it only when taking James to collect it. 8. Alexander joined the Bar-Kays not as a musician but as a bass tech—bringing his instrument to rehearsals so the actual bassist could use it; when the bassist missed a session, the band pointed at Alexander and said he was now the bassist. 9. The original Bar-Kays included a white keyboardist who transferred from a white school to the predominantly Black Booker T. Washington High School over his parents' objections; the Black students accepted him fully and he had a Black girlfriend. 10. The groove that became Soul Finger was discovered accidentally at age 16 while playing an illegal nightclub gig; the Vice Squad would jail young musicians but instead called their parents, so the risk was managed. 11. Steve Cropper, Stax's A&R man, rejected them twice; Jim Stewart—label co-owner—heard them leaving after the second rejection, invited them to a private Sunday session, and the full track was recorded in 30 minutes. 12. David Porter crossed the street to a convenience store, bought a case of Coca-Cola, recruited neighborhood kids, placed them around a single mic, and directed them to shout 'Soul Finger'—paying each child one 10-ounce bottle. 13. Alexander describes the Memphis musical ecosystem as one in which future legends—Isaac Hayes, David Porter, and others—were encountered casually through shared circuits of clubs, bands, and recording sessions. 14. Beale Street in its heyday combined prostitution, drugs, and music; club owner Sunveen Mitchell provided rooms and bowls of chili to touring musicians who couldn't stay in segregated Memphis hotels. 15. Black musicians in white Memphis clubs performed on stages enclosed by guardrails, accessed only from a rear parking lot door, explicitly preventing contact between Black performers and white patrons. 16. Alexander performed for a year at the Plantation Inn in West Memphis with Isaac Hayes and the Doodads—nine to three, six nights a week, 45 minutes on and 15 off, learning jazz standards including 'My Funny Valentine' and 'The Nearness of You' while still in high school. 17. Elvis Presley hired the band for a private party at the same guardrail club, paid the group approximately $500, and then personally gave each of the six musicians a $100 bill—nearly tripling Alexander's night—which James gave immediately to his mother. 18. The interview style is conversational and unhurried; Questlove frequently interjects with context or parallel examples (Ray Parker Jr. vs. Huey Lewis, the Bill Street ecosystem question), while Alexander storytells in careful chronological detail. 19. Best for listeners interested in Stax Records, Memphis music history, and first-person accounts of segregation-era performance economics and race in the music industry. 20. Listeners wanting a focused performance discussion rather than a comprehensive life story will find the episode's broad biographical scope demanding.

As heard by us

A working-musician piece that puts survival ahead of glamour.

It frames working musicianship as labor before legend, following a blunt question about whether a local player could make a living at all. The answer is grounded in routine: factory shifts in places like Detroit, the rust belt, Ohio, and Indiana, then late nights in bars before…

Read the full review in PlayNext →

Why you'd press play

You want the real price of being a working musician.

Read the full recommendation in PlayNext →

Listen to the show on

Apple Podcasts Spotify

Play clips from this episode More from The Questlove Show