The Political Trenches: Local Government At Work · The Political Trenches

5.02: Manitoba Municipal Administrators

February 2, 2026·43 min·2 clips

He says local bylaws can become null and void when they conflict with provincial or federal acts.

1. The Political Trenches: Local Government At Work focuses this episode on municipal administration, cross-border policy, and Manitoba Municipal Administrators. 2. Host Chris is joined later by Nicole Shikoda, President of the Manitoba Municipal Administrators and City of Portage la Prairie CAO, plus Executive Director Adrienne Bestland. 3. The episode asks what municipalities can and cannot do when councils, provinces, and federal governments pull in different directions. 4. Smith Falls, Ontario, becomes the first case study after councillors Jay Brennan and Stephen Robinson are suspended over vulgar remarks caught on a hot microphone. 5. The hosts note that the suspension happened without an integrity commissioner investigation, and legal experts questioned whether council had the authority to act unilaterally. 6. Ian argues that due process still matters even when the facts appear self-evident, because rules on the books are meant to be followed. 7. He says legislative paramountcy means a provincial or federal act prevails when it conflicts with a local bylaw or policy. 8. The discussion also points to Ontario’s system of integrity commissioners and a provincial bill meant to standardize codes of conduct and require independent investigations before suspensions or removals. 9. The episode then moves to Prince George, where the city launched a federal petition calling on Ottawa to act on public safety and justice system capacity. 10. The petition seeks tougher bail rules for repeat and non-violent offenders, more judges and prosecutors, more Crown counsel funding, and more correctional and rehabilitation resources. 11. The hosts say the petition needed 500 signatures in 60 days and had already gathered about 650 after only a few days. 12. Ian says the petition is aimed more at responding after crime happens than at reducing crime in the first place. 13. He also notes that the petitioner is the mayor, which gives the effort more municipal cachet than a petition from a private resident. 14. Winnipeg’s story shifts the conversation to Canada-U.S. relations through Councillor Russ Wyatt’s motion to end a $30,000 annual membership in the North American Strategy for Competitiveness. 15. The same motion would stop city-funded travel related to the Red River Basin Commission, and the hosts weigh the value of those ties against public reluctance to travel south. 16. The discussion turns practical when Ian points out that the Red River runs north, so Minnesota conditions affect Winnipeg flood planning and basin work. 17. The interview segment starts with Nicole Shikoda explaining that CAOs take council’s vision and turn it into reality through staff, budgets, projects, policy, and strategic planning. 18. Adrienne Bestland says Manitoba has no mandatory CAO certification, but the Certificate of Manitoba Municipal Administration is offered with the University of Manitoba and the Act has not changed since 1997. 19. The conversation is conversational and practical, with long back-and-forth answers about mentorship, communication, resilience, and the value of peer networks for administrators. 20. Municipal staff, councillors, and local-government listeners will get the most from this episode, while listeners who want lighter topics or no governance detail may skip it.

As heard by us

A practical tour of municipal pressure points, from cross-border politics to local integrity rules.

The episode treats local government as something that has to be handled, not just commented on. Winnipeg's cross-border questions, Prince George's push for stronger action on public safety and justice, and Smiths Falls' integrity dispute all feed into a larger look at the CAO…

Read the full review in PlayNext →

Why you'd press play

You want a clear read on how local government handles real pressure.

Read the full recommendation in PlayNext →

Listen to the show on

Apple Podcasts Spotify

Play clips from this episode More from The Political Trenches: Local Government At Work