The Pirate History Podcast · Matt Albers

Episode 359 - The Root of All Evil

·44 min·2 clips

By Diocletian's reign, a Roman aureus was worth 16,000 denarii, not 25.

Matt opens where the Quelch trial should have ended. Instead of staying in the dock, he follows the money, because the episode's real point is that piracy, empire, and confidence in currency are tangled together in ways you do not get from a simple courtroom recap. He says the subject is a bit outside his lane, and that turns into a slower, more careful explanation of why coinage matters when a political system is already showing cracks. The main idea is confidence. If people stop believing the coins in their hands are worth what they claim, then prices, payments, and state power all start wobbling at once. Rome gets the long look. The episode walks through a late imperial world where silver has been driven down to almost nothing, gold has also been debased, and barter starts creeping back into ordinary life. That is not a subtle warning sign. It becomes part of the crisis of the third century, which the episode frames as a chain of invasion, rebellion, famine, and plague made worse by failing currency. Diocletian then steps in. His answer is reform: new standardized coins, strict enforcement, and a renewed attempt to make the public believe the system again. The episode names two coins. The gold coin is the solidus and the silver coin is the libra. They were first minted in Nicomedia, and later, under Constantine, they were minted in Constantinople and back in Rome itself. That detail does most of the work. It shows how currency can be more than a medium of exchange, because it can also be a political claim that a state still knows what it is doing. The digression is broad, but it earns its keep by giving the Quelch story a larger frame, so the pirate trial lands inside a history of economic strain rather than floating off as a one-off legal curiosity. Matt closes the loop cleanly. By the end, the listener has a better sense of why money, law, and imperial stability all live in the same neighborhood, which is exactly the kind of patient historical detour this show likes to take.

As heard by us

A pirate trial becomes a lesson in how money, empire, and trust shape history.

The episode starts with the John Quelch trial and then widens into the economic policy of the period, which gives the story more shape than a simple courtroom recap.

Read the full review in PlayNext →

Why you'd press play

You want a pirate story that keeps pulling the thread into the money system.

Read the full recommendation in PlayNext →

Listen to the show on

Apple Podcasts Spotify

Play clips from this episode More from The Pirate History Podcast