The People's Pharmacy · Joe and Terry Graedon

Show 1434: Digital Doctoring: Will AI Save Lives or Cause Medical Mayhem?

June 12, 2025·1 hr 10 min·5 clips
An AI chatbot gave more empathetic counseling than Dr. Chen in a tough conversation about a feeding tube for dementia.
Joe and Terry Graydon open with a health headlines segment. They note that COVID-19 rates are currently low. They then turn to newer research on long-term cardiac complications. A study in JAMA Network Open suggests that people who were seriously ill with the infection may have reduced blood flow in the small vessels that feed the heart. The condition is described as coronary microvascular dysfunction. It can limit blood flow to the heart under stress. That, in turn, may impair cardiac function. The segment places this finding among several cardiovascular complications that can linger after recovery. The main conversation then shifts to AI in medicine. Dr. Art Papier joins the program. He has developed a decision support system to help healthcare professionals diagnose skin problems. The discussion frames AI as a tool that can support judgment, but not something to lean on too heavily. Papier warns that if people let AI do too much of the work, they may lose some of their natural human ability to think carefully about whether a diagnosis makes sense. The hosts and guest then move toward how patients might use AI themselves. One practical use is translating medical records into plain English. That can be empowering for people who have access to their own charts but find the language hard to parse. Papier says this can help people understand what is happening and take more ownership of their care. He also says that a chatbot should not be treated as the final word. The system can be useful, but it does not take responsibility for care the way a human clinician does. That distinction stays central. Privacy becomes another major concern. Papier reminds listeners that when they enter personal health information into an online chatbot, they are sending private data to a tech company. He treats that as a choice patients should make consciously. The discussion also returns to the limits of expert certainty. Not every doctor is right about everything, and medicine often involves uncertainty. In that setting, a second opinion can be valuable. The same logic applies to AI-generated answers. They can inform a conversation, but they cannot settle it. The final stretch looks at a more subtle problem with chatbots. Papier notes that these systems are designed to be pleasing and to align with user preferences. That can make them feel supportive. It can also make them too eager to confirm what a user already believes. The episode leaves listeners with a balanced view: AI may become powerful in health care, but its benefits depend on safeguards, skepticism, and human judgment staying in the loop.

As heard by us

A practical, skeptical look at AI in medicine that stays grounded.

This episode treats AI in medicine as a working problem, not a slogan. It starts with a COVID-related heart finding, then follows Dr. Art Papier as he makes the case that decision support can help clinicians spot skin problems without pushing human judgment out of the room.

Read the full review in PlayNext →

Why you'd press play

Want a clear-eyed look at AI in medicine without the hype?

Read the full recommendation in PlayNext →
Listen to the show on