The Partially Examined Life Philosophy Podcast · Mark Linsenmayer, Wes Alwan, Seth Paskin, Dylan Casey

PEL Presents PMP#215: Hamnet Dramatizes Shakespeare

·1 hr 4 min·6 clips

Lawrence argues Hamnet is manipulative grief porn that forces emotions instead of earning them.

This episode of Pretty Much Pop features hosts Mark Linton Meyer, Al Baker, Sarah Lynn Breck, and Lawrence discussing Chloe Zhao's film adaptation of Maggie O'Farrell's novel "Hamnet." They examine the movie's portrayal of Shakespeare's personal tragedy and its exploration of grief. The hosts analyze the film's artistic choices and its relationship to the source material. The film dramatizes the death of William Shakespeare's young son, Hamnet, and the subsequent creation of the play "Hamlet." The narrative primarily follows Agnes, Shakespeare's wife, as she experiences this loss. The story employs a five-act structure and uses flashbacks to depict the couple's early romance. A significant subplot involves a foretelling that Agnes would have only two children, which creates tension when she gives birth to twins, Hamnet and Judith. The novel includes a detailed section tracing the plague's journey from Alexandria to the Shakespeare household. The film's climax features Agnes attending a performance of "Hamlet," where Shakespeare plays the ghost. A key scene involves Agnes realizing the play serves as a metaphor for her grief when she focuses on an archway on stage. The movie diverges from the book by incorporating direct Shakespearean quotations into dialogue. One insight is that the film intentionally forces viewers to sit with prolonged, uncomfortable scenes of grief to make the emotional payoff meaningful. The hosts debate whether this directorial choice is artistically valid or emotionally manipulative. Lawrence argues the film feels like "grief porn" and Oscar bait, designed to elicit tears through overt means rather than subtle storytelling. Al counters that the lingering scenes ground the story in emotional reality and serve a clear thematic purpose. The discussion notes that public displays of grief in the film might be anachronistic, though the private feeling of loss is historically accurate. Sarah highlights how the story challenges the notion that parents in the Renaissance were less attached to their children due to high mortality rates. The conversation is analytical and critical, with hosts frequently debating and challenging each other's interpretations. The tone is passionate and conversational, blending personal reaction with formal critique. Listeners engage with detailed plot and thematic analysis. This episode will appeal to fans of literary adaptations, film criticism, and deep dives into themes of art and grief. Listeners who enjoy debates about directorial choices and narrative structure will find it compelling. Those seeking a lighthearted or purely plot-summary discussion might prefer to skip it, given the heavy subject matter and critical debate.

As heard by us

A skeptical, lively discussion of Hamnet that weighs grief, Shakespeare, and awards-season suspicion.

Pretty Much Pop treats Chloe Zhao's Hamnet as a talky, skeptical take on Shakespeare, grief, and the awards-season logic behind prestige film.

Read the full review in PlayNext →

Why you'd press play

If you want a funny, sharp argument about Chloe Zhao's Oscar-nominated Hamnet, start here.

Read the full recommendation in PlayNext →

Listen to the show on

Apple Podcasts Spotify

Play clips from this episode More from The Partially Examined Life Philosophy Podcast