The Partially Examined Life Philosophy Podcast · Mark Linsenmayer, Wes Alwan, Seth Paskin, Dylan Casey

Ep. 387: Hegel on Law (Part Two)

·1 hr 1 min·5 clips

Oedipus does not recognize the father in the man who has wronged him and whom he slays.

The panel keeps working through Hegel on spirit. They pick up at section 469 and use guilt to connect the human law and the divine law, treating each deed as something that activates the other side. The Oedipus metaphor comes up next. One host wonders whether the reference is explicit here or only implicit, and the group settles on the idea that the deed traps the doer by closing the gap between what is known and what is actually there. That makes crime the hinge. It is the point where the unconscious becomes conscious and where guilt becomes readable in the act itself. From there the panel turns to the nation. They describe its natural, unconscious calm and set it against self-consciousness, which pushes back by turning the whole into separate individuals. The break matters. Once the social substance is shattered, the individual gains a formal universality and an immediate relation to law, the sort of relation the discussion keeps comparing to Kant. Kant does come up by name, and one host pushes back by recalling the internalizing reading associated with Korsgaard. Atomization then becomes the key word. The panel points out that Hannah Arendt will later pick up the term, but Hegel already has it in play. Legal status follows. That section is treated as the next move in the same story of alienation, with a soulless community left where a living spirit once seemed to dwell. The discussion stays practical about the reading. Rather than forcing one answer out of the section, they keep circling the lines and checking which reading fits the legal, religious, or political wording best. Rome hovers in the background. The episode keeps returning to that modern, formal attitude toward law while the panel tries to say how the whole social world got there.

As heard by us

Hegel's law, guilt, and atomization become a live argument instead of a neat summary.

This episode keeps returning to Hegel's account of spirit, guilt, and the split between human law and divine law, then turns that pressure toward the Oedipus metaphor and the idea that action can bring the unconscious into view by becoming crime.

Read the full review in PlayNext →

Why you'd press play

You get Hegel, guilt, and legal alienation without anyone pretending it is simple.

Read the full recommendation in PlayNext →

Listen to the show on

Apple Podcasts Spotify

Play clips from this episode More from The Partially Examined Life Philosophy Podcast