The Occurrence in River Oaks · Nikki Durbin

Episode One: Initiation

January 17, 2024·21 min·2 clips

Paul reports Miss McKay's front door has been ripped off its hinges, suggesting something far worse than a missing dog.

The episode opens with dispatcher Olivia arriving late to work and settling into warm banter with her partner Alan, who is nearing retirement. Their easy friendship is established through jokes about donuts, a shared interest in Sam Witwer's music, and good-natured ribbing. Olivia conducts morning check-ins with the rest of the small patrol team: Howard returning from sick leave, the twins Paul and Paula, and Eric, the new officer who keeps forgetting to turn his radio on. Eric and Olivia share a brief, tentative connection when she helps him navigate the town and he learns she writes screenplays. Miss McKay, a known local character, manages to reach the dispatch radio because her landline is out, one of several GPS and phone outages mentioned. She describes seeing a creature at the edge of her property before dawn that she says resembled an oversized crawdad with too many eyestalks, moving faster than a rabbit. Her dog Buster chased it into the woods and has not returned. The officers joke about her reputation as someone who regularly causes town-wide panics, most recently by scaring people with a fog bank she described as sheets of paper in the sky. Despite the jokes, Olivia sends Paul and Paula to the address. While waiting, Olivia hints to Alan that things at home are difficult, suggesting problems with her mother, though she does not elaborate. Paul calls in to report that Miss McKay's front door appears to have been ripped completely off its hinges, a detail inconsistent with the actions of any normal person or animal. Maria volunteers to head over as backup, noting she wants to see the door herself. Alan leaves to get sandwiches from across the street, joking his way out the door as Olivia tells him she has a bad feeling. The episode ends when the officers at the scene hear something large moving inside the house, and the radio connection cuts off ambiguously.

As heard by us

A sleepy police shift gets upended by a creature report that feels half joke, half threat.

Occurrence in River Oaks starts with a sleepy police-comedy setup and then swerves when Miss McKay reports a giant crawdad-like creature. That contrast does the heavy lifting: the ordinary morning feels sturdy enough that the absurdity lands instead of just drifting by.

Read the full review in PlayNext →

Why you'd press play

You want a deadpan dispatch opener that stays casual until one bizarre call yanks the room off balance.

Read the full recommendation in PlayNext →

Listen to the show on

Apple Podcasts Spotify

Play clips from this episode More from The Occurrence in River Oaks