The Next Best Picture Podcast

"You, Me & Tuscany"

·59 min·5 clips
Why a studio executive won't buy a rom-com until they see how 'You, Me, and Tuscany' performs at the box office.
The episode begins with the trailer's setup for You, Me, and Tuscany. Anna is a free-spirited young cook who makes the bold choice to squat in an abandoned Tuscan villa. The property belongs to a man she barely knows, and Michael enters the picture as the homeowner's cousin. A fake engagement soon becomes part of the story when Anna is asked to pretend to be Matteo's fiance. The discussion treats that arrangement as a source of romantic possibility and comic confusion, while also poking at how the film handles the relationships around Isabella and Matteo. One line from Michael gets special attention: he says he always falls for the wrong girl. A guest wonders whether that line points to some earlier connection between Michael and Isabella, since Isabella and Mateo are together and also competitive. The possibility is left mostly unexplored, which pushes the conversation toward a larger question: is the script simply keeping things light, or are viewers adding more complexity than the movie intends? The film's fairy-tale quality becomes the next major point of debate. The premise asks the audience to accept a down-on-her-luck girl traveling to Italy and living out a dream that includes falling in love with Rege-Jean Page. The discussion accepts that romantic comedies need fantasy, but it also asks when that fantasy starts to feel more irritating than charming. From there, the episode turns to the theatrical future of the genre. It asks whether a hypothetical weak theatrical performance would suggest that the rom-com itself is finished in cinemas. Another possibility is that the result would say more about how much movie stars still matter to the formula. Anyone But You comes up as a recent film with Sidney Sweeney and Glenn Powell that made a lot of money. The conversation links that success to a longer history of rom-coms helping stars begin and build their careers, then asks whether the current film landscape has enough comparable stars. The episode keeps circling the tension between an inviting fantasy and a screenplay whose loose threads are hard not to tug on. It also identifies Kat Coyro as director and Ryan Engel as writer.

As heard by us

A relaxed rom-com discussion about fantasy, loose plot threads, and theatrical star power.

The Next Best Picture Podcast approaches You, Me & Tuscany as a modern romantic-comedy fantasy built around an abandoned villa, a bold trip to Italy, and a fake-fiance mix-up.

Read the full review in PlayNext →

Why you'd press play

Press play for a clear-eyed rom-com check-in on the fantasy packed into a Tuscan villa, a fake engagement, and one very brash trip to Italy.

Read the full recommendation in PlayNext →
Listen to the show on