"You, Me & Tuscany"

·59 min·5 clips

Why a studio executive won't buy a rom-com until they see how 'You, Me, and Tuscany' performs at the box office.

The episode begins with a trailer recap and introduction of the film 'You, Me, and Tuscany', directed by Kat Coyro and written by Ryan and Kristen Engel. The host explains the motivation for reviewing this film, citing a tweet from Nina Lee about studios monitoring its performance to decide on buying other black-led rom-coms. This leads to a broader discussion on the challenges faced by non-white stories in Hollywood, with examples like 'Crazy Rich Asians' and 'Sinners'. Katie Johnson, a rom-com fan, shares her thoughts, noting the packed audience and criticizing the script's juvenile humor while appreciating the bright cinematography. Dan Baer admits the film isn't great but enjoyed it for its charm, communal theater experience, and cast performances. The hosts delve into plot details, including the premise of Anna squatting in a Tuscan villa and the ensuing lies, highlighting the lack of stakes and convenient resolutions. They analyze the chemistry between Halle Bailey and Regé-Jean Page, debating their star power and career choices, with Dan lamenting Regé-Jean Page's missed opportunity for James Bond. Other cast members like Lorenzo De Mor and Aziza Scott are praised for their comedic timing. The conversation covers genre tropes, food imagery, ADR issues, and comparisons to other rom-coms like 'Letters to Juliet' and 'Anyone but You'. Final thoughts include ratings and box office predictions, with hopes that the film's success could pave the way for more diverse projects. The episode ends with host sign-offs and podcast promotion.

As heard by us

A relaxed rom-com discussion about fantasy, loose plot threads, and theatrical star power.

The Next Best Picture Podcast approaches You, Me & Tuscany as a modern romantic-comedy fantasy built around an abandoned villa, a bold trip to Italy, and a fake-fiance mix-up.

Read the full review in PlayNext →

Why you'd press play

Press play for a clear-eyed rom-com check-in on the fantasy packed into a Tuscan villa, a fake engagement, and one very brash trip to Italy.

Read the full recommendation in PlayNext →

Listen to the show on

Apple Podcasts Spotify

Play clips from this episode More from The Next Best Picture Podcast