The MixTape podcast · Movie Review Podcast

I Know What You Did Last Summer ''1997�'' film

July 7, 2025·1 hr 10 min·3 clips

They hit a person and Barry wants to dump the body - while Ray just watches and does nothing.

Dane and Marcella go deep on I Know What You Did Last Summer. They treat the 1997 Jim Gillespie movie like a screenwriting case study, keep reminding each other that Kevin Williamson took a lot of liberties from Lois Duncan’s novel, and make a point of saying the book is completely different. That matters here. The conversation keeps circling back to how the screenplay turns a familiar hook-wielding maniac setup into something tightly arranged, with small beats doing more work than they first seem to. The opening gets plenty of love. They start with the camera pushing over the ocean, talk through the quick setup, and keep admiring how fast the movie moves from mood to motion without wasting time. Barry catches heat. When Barry goes after Max and accuses him of writing the letter, the hosts read the scene as more than a blowup, because it also helps set Max up as a possible killer and makes the movie feel sneakier. Max gets weirdly bright. They notice that after Barry walks away, Max is on cloud nine, which gives the character a sharp edge and makes the suspicion around him feel earned. Julie and Ray get dragged. The reunion between Julie and Ray becomes one of the episode’s biggest arguments, first because Julie’s line to him is unbelievably harsh, and then because the hosts talk themselves through the fact that Ray never backed her up when Barry choked her out of the car. The crab bit lands. They clock Max on the docks, notice him putting crabs into boiling pots, call it odd, and use it as a good example of the movie choosing image and attitude over tidy realism. Setup matters. Again and again, the hosts return to audience alignment, misdirection, and whether a scene actually pushes the story forward, which is exactly the kind of blunt craft talk the show is built for. The energy stays loose and conversational, with the two hosts pushing and correcting each other in a way that keeps the episode moving. By the end, they frame the film as something worth showing in screenwriting classes, then bounce out toward next week’s Bram Stoker’s Dracula and the usual sign-off about subscribing and emailing the show.

As heard by us

A sharp slasher rewatch that prizes setup, payoff, and character pressure.

PlayNext's Mixtape Podcast take on I Know What You Did Last Summer stays firmly in screenwriter mode, treating the film as craft rather than nostalgia.

Read the full review in PlayNext →

Why you'd press play

You want a 1997 slasher recapped with a screenwriter's eye.

Read the full recommendation in PlayNext →

Listen to the show on

Apple Podcasts Spotify

Play clips from this episode More from The MixTape podcast