The Megyn Kelly Show · SiriusXM

Disturbing Jared From Subway Story, Casey Anthony Trial, Deep Dive Into Cults - Megyn's "True Crime" Mega-Episode

·4 hr 20 min·5 clips
Jared Fogle whispered to Rochelle Herman how hot he thought middle school girls were during a school event.
The ad reads move fast. Then the host warns that the Jared from Subway archive is disturbing and says, plainly, that even people who know the story should hear it again. The details are awful. The segment closes in on Russell, the stepfather described as putting cameras around the home and giving material to Jared Fogle. The daughters speak in a way that is hard to shake. They describe FBI questioning, hidden cameras in private spaces, and the sick shock of realizing they had been watched all the time. The host does not clean it up for comfort. She reacts with revulsion, then follows the case from Russell to Jared and from Jared to the search warrant. The computers change everything. Once investigators got to them, the host says they had what they needed, including images, and Jared's old public image broke as the raid became news. That contrast is the point. He had been in living rooms for 15 years as the sweet guy next door, until the arrest and home raid changed how everyone saw him. The interview stays right on that moment. The host asks what it felt like when the raid went public, while keeping the judgment blunt. Then the excerpt jumps to Casey Anthony. This section has a different kind of disbelief, built around her walking police through Universal as if she had a reason to be there. The lie keeps going. She names people, gets through security, passes employees, and finally reaches the end of the story. Then she admits she does not work there. The host's point lands dry: the police already knew.

As heard by us

A blunt true crime sampler that favors momentum and plainspoken judgment over mood.

Megyn Kelly's true-crime roundup stays focused on cases where public image and private behavior do not match. The Jared from Subway segment does most of the heavy lifting, leaning on a first-hand account from someone who worked undercover with the FBI and a brisk, skeptical…

Read the full review in PlayNext →

Why you'd press play

You want dark true-crime clips, pulled from the archives and centered on the Jared from Subway case.

Read the full recommendation in PlayNext →
Listen to the show on