The London Lyceum · Jordan Steffaniak

Revolutionizing Church History with Steve McKinion, Thomas Kidd, and Benjamin Quinn

April 8, 2026·50 min·4 clips
Three scholars discuss their new two-volume church history textbook and how it differs from traditional approaches.
1. The London Lyceum hosts a roundtable with three scholars — Steve McKinnon, Benjamin Quinn, and Thomas Kidd — about their new two-volume church history published with B&H Academic. 2. Host Leland Brown is joined by co-host Hunter Heinzman; the guests are introduced with their current institutional positions and research projects, including Kidd's forthcoming biography of Adoniram Judson with Jason Duesing. 3. The core thesis of the episode is that a new church history textbook is needed that recovers the great tradition for a generation preparing for global ministry and mission. 4. McKinnon explains that the project was originally conceived as a single-volume historical theology text focused on development of doctrine, but became a two-volume church history at the publisher's suggestion — provided the authors could maintain a historically theological rather than purely social-history approach. 5. The two-volume set is consciously positioned against Justo Gonzalez's standard text, maintaining Gonzalez's narrative strength while adding more theological weight — specifically weaving together liturgy, morality, and creedal commitments as expressions of the same handed-down faith. 6. Quinn draws on 2 Thessalonians 2 and 3 to argue that 'tradition' in the Pauline sense encompasses both propositional content and a way of life, and that both must appear in any faithful telling of church history. 7. Kidd argues that Thomas Kidd argues that most traditional church history textbooks have been written from a perspective that treats theological novelty as progress and downplays conservative responses, citing the old Princeton theologians as an example of a robust traditional response to Darwinism and Schleiermacher that is often ignored. 8. On the global church question, Kidd draws on Philip Jenkins's The Next Christendom to argue that Africa is now the demographic centre of world Christianity — for Pentecostals, Anglicans, and Catholics alike — and that this shift makes a global perspective more urgent than ever. 9. Quinn explains the consultation process for writing outside one's specialty: for chapters on Irenaeus he called Stephen Presley, for Aquinas he asked Ross Inman and worked through a reading list of 55 books, then selected the most essential material for a seminary audience. 10. McKinnon argues that the governing discipline in writing a survey textbook is the refusal to be encyclopedic — textbooks are tertiary sources, so authors pick a path through existing secondary debates rather than surface every historiographical controversy. 11. Kidd notes a counterintuitive advantage of writing outside one's specialty: you avoid getting bogged down in scholarly debates that students generally do not need to encounter, and you can be clearer precisely because you are not invested in the inside arguments. 12. The panel discusses painful editorial cuts: McKinnon regrets insufficient coverage of monasticism as a missionary movement rather than a purely institutional phenomenon; Quinn deleted four subheadings on medieval mystics and the desert fathers and mothers. 13. Kidd describes his approach as consciously limiting space given to Schleiermacher and other progressive theologians, saying evangelical seminary students need to know who Schleiermacher is and then move on, in contrast to textbooks that spend disproportionate time on such figures. 14. Host Heinzman observes that this may be 'the first time five Baptists have ever been on a podcast longing to spend more time with medieval mystics and just not caring that much about modern liberals' — a line the panel endorses. 15. The conversation addresses how to write church history as Baptists — neither as Landmarkists who see only the Baptist lineage as valid, nor as those who simply borrow horizontally from other traditions, but as heirs of a great tradition that predates and forms them. 16. Kidd notes that his Baptist identity leads to more coverage of the conservative resurgence in the Southern Baptist Convention than a non-Baptist author would provide, while acknowledging the book was written with an awareness of the broader evangelical tradition. 17. McKinnon argues that Baptists are sometimes tempted to think either that their own tradition is the only valid one or to see other traditions merely as sources to mine horizontally, when the better frame is that the entire great tradition is their inherited history. 18. The episode format is a roundtable with three academic guests and two hosts, conversational in tone but with extended substantive exchanges about historiography, global Christianity, and theological method. 19. Seminarians, pastors, and Christian educators who want to understand the rationale behind a new church history textbook and engage questions of how to teach church history faithfully will find this episode directly relevant. 20. Listeners without background in theological education or church history historiography may find the discussions of Gonzalez, Jenkins, Liz Clark, and Schleiermacher difficult to follow without prior context.

As heard by us

A careful church history discussion that treats method, audience, and scholarly discipline as central, not incidental.

The London Lyceum uses a new two-volume introduction to church history to ask a practical question: how should the church's past be written without sanding off its complexity?

Read the full review in PlayNext →

Why you'd press play

For a careful look at how church history gets written for the next generation.

Read the full recommendation in PlayNext →
Listen to the show on