The London Lyceum · Jordan Steffaniak

How Augustine Shapes Christian Scholarship and Public Life with John Wilsey and Stephen Presley

March 25, 2026·51 min·3 clips
Stephen Presley reads aloud Augustine's commentary on John 1:12, culminating in the line 'The Word was not ashamed to be born of man—are men ashamed to be born of God?'
1. The London Lyceum episode brings together hosts Jordan Stefaniak and Hunter with regular guests Dr. Stephen Presley (patristics scholar) and Dr. John Wilsey (American historian) to discuss Augustine of Hippo's influence on Christian scholarship and public life. 2. Stephen Presley's interests in Augustine center on De Doctrina Christiana, the Enchiridion, and the City of God, especially the second half where Augustine narrates salvation history from Genesis to Revelation; John Wilsey describes Augustine as a 'hobby' who has shaped his metaphysics. 3. The episode's core question is how Augustine's theological framework—grounding all reality in the triune God and ordering theology before epistemology before ethics before politics—provides resources for contemporary Christian public engagement. 4. John Wilsey argues that the question 'Does God exist?' is philosophically absurd because it takes the universe for granted; following Augustine's Confessions and Anselm's Monologion and Proslogion, he proposes that taking God's existence as given raises the more interesting question: why does the universe exist at all? 5. He cites Revelation 5—'You created all things; because of your pleasure they existed and were created'—as Augustine's answer, calling creation 'a pure act of grace that God makes anything and shares existence with anything.' 6. Presley identifies the City of God's first half (Augustine's critique of Greco-Roman philosophy) as favored by scholars interested in political thought, while the second half (salvation history from Genesis to Revelation) is favored by theologians. 7. Hunter challenges the panel: citing Augustine does not establish the patristic position—his best ideas come from Origen and Justin Martyr, while his distinctive innovations like infant baptism are uniquely Augustinian—which the other hosts greet with amusement and partial agreement. 8. Presley distinguishes two contemporary receptions of Augustine: Jack Caputo's On Religion, which borrows Augustine's 'What do I love when I love my God?' to ask only 'How do I love?' while dropping the metaphysical question; and Catholic integralism, which uses Augustine to tie metaphysical convictions tightly to political theology. 9. Wilsey argues that starting with politics as a branch of ethics—as Marxist thought does following Aristotle—inevitably produces the tendency to politicize every domain of public life, citing Olympic athletes and Hollywood actors as examples. 10. By contrast, Wilsey presents Augustine's order—God first, then epistemology, then ethics, then political theory—as the alternative that grounds a more durable public theology, and applies it to his own book on religious freedom. 11. He notes the Augustine-vs-Marx difference: both see history as a story of conflict, but Marx's conflict is material and irresolvable, while Augustine's is spiritual—city of man versus city of God—and resolved by God's kingdom filling the earth. 12. Presley argues that Augustine's approach to scripture—making the Bible the 'center of their orbit' rather than one input among many—is essential for Christian political engagement and that modern biblical studies' sequestration from other disciplines is a serious problem. 13. He reads aloud from Augustine's Commentary on John, delivering the passage on John 1:12–14 that climaxes with: 'The Word was not ashamed to be born of man. Are men ashamed to be born of God?' 14. Both guests recommend starting with Augustine's Confessions or De Doctrina Christiana as entry points, with the Enchiridion as a second; Presley adds the works on Trinity, catechesis, and faith and the creed. 15. Wilsey recommends City of God as a 'lifetime project,' advising patience, slow reading, and giving oneself 'a couple of years' to work through it. 16. Presley invokes C.S. Lewis's introduction to Athanasius's On the Incarnation to argue that primary sources are often more accessible than the secondary literature written about them. 17. Wilsey articulates an Augustinian theology of historical study: we love historical figures because God made them as image-bearers; the Christian can also claim present connection through Christ with any fellow believer across history. 18. The tone is collegial and wide-ranging—the hosts and guests interrupt frequently, share jokes about pronouncing 'Augustine' vs. 'Augustine,' and engage in genuine scholarly disagreement about the relative importance of Augustine versus the ante-Nicene fathers. 19. The episode is aimed at pastors, seminarians, and educated laypeople interested in Augustine, patristics, public theology, and how classical Christian thought applies to contemporary political questions. 20. Listeners seeking practical ministry advice, rapid-fire discussion, or content outside Christian theology and intellectual history will find the episode slow and highly technical.

As heard by us

A patient Augustine discussion about political life, theology, and why politics should not come first.

The episode keeps Augustine at the center, with John Wilsey and Stephen Presley tracing how his thought shapes their scholarship and their view of political life.

Read the full review in PlayNext →

Why you'd press play

If Augustine, political theology, and religious freedom sound worth your time.

Read the full recommendation in PlayNext →
Listen to the show on