The London Lyceum · Jordan Steffaniak

Academic Conferences with Stephen Presley and John Wilsey

September 17, 2025·56 min·4 clips
Stephen Presley describes academic conferences as the place where 'your footnotes are walking around and you could go meet them.'
Academic conferences are not neutral rooms. This conversation puts friendship, witness, scholarship, and spiritual judgment in the same hallway and asks what Christians should do there. The host starts with serious habits for the church: charity, curiosity, critical thinking, and cheerful confessionalism. Baptist conviction stays clear, but the opening also pushes back on treating non-Baptists as outsiders by default. Wilsey makes the case for wider company. Scholars should be willing to enter conferences where not everyone shares their assumptions, because colleagues do not have to become spiritual counselors to become genuinely helpful friends. That distinction carries much of the episode. Some friends are the people one calls for spiritual counsel. Others are academic companions whose friendship is still real, even across theological distance. The tone loosens for a moment with stories from conferences without many believers, described as wild, followed by the careful joke that no law-breaking or immorality is being confessed. Then the point gets sharper. A terminal degree, one guest says, does not erase the ordinary truth that all have sinned and fallen short of God's glory. Scholarship does not make anyone holy on its own. That turns the conference hall into a pastoral and evangelistic field, not just a professional setting. Leland's work enters here, connecting early church pastoral theology with the task of speaking patiently to pagans, pagan ideas, and people who need theological truth. The academic Christian can attend ETS and still learn to listen, speak, and bear witness among scholars outside the same confessional world.

As heard by us

A measured case for learning from people who are not always on your side.

The discussion makes a practical case for showing up at conferences alongside people who do not always think alike. It argues that these settings can still grow good friendships and useful collegiality, even if they are not the right place for spiritual counsel or for working…

Read the full review in PlayNext →

Why you'd press play

When you want a calm case for disagreement without losing your footing.

Read the full recommendation in PlayNext →
Listen to the show on