The Jaipur Dialogues Podcasts

Ultimate Pakistan Meltdown on Dhurandhar | Aalia Shah, Sanjay Dixit

·42 min·4 clips
The concept of Ghazwa-e-Hind is reversed as Pakistan makes claims on Afghanistan and Iran.
The discussion opens around Pakistan and Israel. It asks why relations with Israel should remain impossible. A reference to Quran 5.82 brings religious interpretation into the debate. The speakers push back against using old books to handle the present world. They argue that Pakistan has to do more if it wants to move forward in the current age. The conversation recalls talk that relations with Israel were being considered during Imran Khan's government. It also mentions claims that steps toward Israel were happening secretly. The central problem becomes fear. Pakistan fears the people it helped create through madrasa and religious messaging. The discussion names Jews, Hindus, and Christians as groups presented to those people as enemies. Palestine adds another heavy source of pressure. Public anger could follow any visible relationship with Israel because of Palestinians. Religious feeling makes the issue even more volatile. The speakers say Pakistan has made that sentiment powerful through its own religious environment. They argue that the decision may still have to be taken eventually. The TLP is cited as a force that came into the streets and was beaten back. The conversation says no one can stop a determined move if the authorities choose to make it. Statements made to scholars and to Iran are presented as difficult acts taken despite surrounding sentiment. The speakers acknowledge that such moves can bring backlash. The discussion then pivots to mischief associated with Devbandi boys. Aligarh and Syed Ahmed enter the exchange as the speakers compare different circles and briefly return to TLP. The final mood loosens into banter about Muneer, whose kite is said to be flying very high and who is said to have hit the jackpot, before the speakers thank one another and the viewers.

As heard by us

Pakistan's Israel dilemma becomes a pointed study of foreign policy, religious sentiment, and public backlash.

The episode frames Pakistan's possible relations with Israel as a problem of political risk, showing how religious sentiment, Palestine, and public backlash narrow the room for governments that are said to have considered such moves, sometimes quietly.

Read the full review in PlayNext →

Why you'd press play

Want Pakistan's Israel question served with religious sentiment, street pressure, Palestine, and one very high kite?

Read the full recommendation in PlayNext →
Listen to the show on