EV or ICE? Alpine A290 GTS v Volkswagen Polo GTI

February 5, 2026·14 min·1 clip

Andrew Frankel decides if the Alpine A290 GTS can finally beat the ancient Volkswagen Polo GTI in a hot hatch showdown.

This episode is a head-to-head comparison between the new electric Alpine A290 GTS and the traditional Volkswagen Polo GTI, narrated by automotive journalist Andrew Frankel. Frankel conducts a real-world test to determine if an electric hot hatch can outperform its internal combustion engine rival. The test immediately highlights a critical practical challenge for the EV. The Alpine's journey from Bristol to a Welsh photoshoot location was severely delayed by unreliable public charging infrastructure. Frankel notes the Alpine attempted to use a 200kW charger but only received 23kW, causing a 40-minute late arrival with minimal remaining range. This charging issue forced the team to compromise on their preferred photography location due to a lack of decent nearby chargers. The Volkswagen Polo GTI, in contrast, arrived on time without any need to stop for fuel. Frankel points out the Polo GTI is often overlooked, positioned between its more famous Golf and Up siblings. He mentions the Polo model line has survived for nearly 50 years, celebrating its half-century recently. A compelling insight is how the EV's operational flaws, not its driving dynamics, dominated the initial comparison. The narrative frames the charging anxiety as a potential deal-breaker for time-sensitive commitments like job interviews or flight catchings. Frankel personifies the cars, suggesting the reliable Polo would look "smug" given its hassle-free journey. The test underscores that for many buyers, the ownership experience extends beyond pure performance metrics. The episode sets up a tension between the promise of new electric performance and the ingrained convenience of fossil fuels. The tone is narrative and experiential, blending technical automotive critique with a relatable story of a road trip gone wrong. The style is conversational and reflective, using personal anecdote to illustrate broader points about EV adoption. Car enthusiasts curious about the real-world viability of performance EVs would find this episode highly engaging. Listeners solely interested in spec-sheet statistics or who are sensitive to criticisms of electric vehicle infrastructure might find its perspective frustrating.

Listen to the show on

Apple Podcasts Spotify

Play clips from this episode More from The Intercooler Audio Articles