The History of Russia Podcast · Damon Boar

Episode 96 - The Pugachevshchina

·26 min

Damon opens by picking back up the thread of Pugachev's rebellion after the earlier sweep through Catherine the Great's empire-building and consolidation. He says this episode will stay with the Pugachevshchina, or the time of Pugachev. He also notes that the long Russian label will not be repeated too often. The episode briefly nods toward the expected court intrigue, then leaves that for later. For now, the rebellion is the thing. Pugachev keeps gathering support by presenting himself as Peter III, and the movement builds enough momentum that Catherine has to treat it as more than a passing disturbance. Some followers seem to believe the claim, while others are probably happy to go along for as long as it works. The episode notes that Pugachev even had a coin minted with his likeness and Peter III's name beneath it. The imperial response arrives in stages. Early attempts to suppress the revolt do not finish the job. Catherine starts to suspect that foreign enemies may have stirred the whole thing up, because of course a rebellion this awkward must have had outside help, mustn't it? General Peter Bibikov then arrives with a larger force and succeeds in relieving Orenburg by routing a rebel army near the town in early March 1774. Nearly half of Pugachev's force is captured. Pugachev and part of his inner circle escape, regroup, and head for the Ural Mountains. Bibikov follows up by telling Catherine that the rebellion looks homegrown rather than foreign-backed. Then he dies of a fever, which is not the sort of administrative continuity anyone enjoys. The Empress assumes the remaining officers will finish the job. For a while, that seems plausible, because silence can look a lot like victory if you are willing to squint hard enough. But Pugachev has not disappeared. On July 11th, 1774, he reappears outside Kazan with an army of around 20,000. The episode shifts from suppression to relapse, because a revolt that large has a way of refusing to behave. Pugachev's renewed presence forces another serious response, and this time the empire sends in Peter Panin. Panin captures Pugachev, who is then put on display in an iron cage and taken to Moscow. The rebellion has reached the point where spectacle and punishment begin to replace uncertainty. The aftermath is not tidy. Pugachev is eventually executed, and Panin is only thanked for his service rather than rewarded. The episode closes by turning to the serfs, who suffer harsher treatment from landowners after the revolt, especially in areas touched by the fighting. In some cases, people suspected of involvement are executed without trial. The ending is grim, which fits, and then Damon points ahead to the next episode, where the court intrigue will finally get its turn. It is a carefully ordered account of how a rebellion grows, survives punishment, and leaves a harsher landscape behind it. The episode keeps asking what was really happening, then answers in stages, which is a good fit for a story like this.

As heard by us

A brisk, disciplined account of rebellion, miscalculation, and the people left to bear the cost.

The episode stays tightly on Pugachev's rebellion, tracing how the crisis keeps shifting through false claims of legitimacy, a failed first effort to end the insurrection, Bibikov's larger force breaking the siege of Orenburg, and Pugachev's return with around 20,000 men to…

Read the full review in PlayNext →

Why you'd press play

Press play if you want Russia to stop being polite and start revolting.

Read the full recommendation in PlayNext →

Listen to the show on

Apple Podcasts Spotify