AAG 1654-1660 Protectorate and Restoration

May 25, 2025·1 hr 8 min·5 clips

Cromwell's court cost a fraction of Charles I's, but royalists mocked his family's lack of grandeur.

Mayhem starts the useful bit. The royalist threat now has company: disappointed Levellers, with Edward Sexby and Killing No Murder right in the danger zone. Then one guard changes the temperature. An assassin inside Cromwell's own guard has second thoughts, confesses, and shows just how shaky the Protectorate has become. Parliament gets its moment back. With MPs returned to the Commons, Conservatives such as Brokill and Whitlock can kill off the Militia Bill and Decimation Tax. The Major Generals are finished. They lasted about 18 months, and the host sounds openly relieved to watch that experiment go into the ground. Still, that only fixes part of the mess. Sexby's plot makes the ugly point hard to dodge: the Republic seems to depend on Cromwell staying alive. So, naturally, another constitutional bodge appears. Brokill, Whitlock, and others push the Humble Petition and Advice to contain radicals and put a leash on the army. The shape looks familiar. A second nominated House turns up, the Council becomes mostly civil, and hereditary succession edges back toward the room. Not the old monarchy, exactly. The host treats it as the ancient Constitution coming back without a sacred absolutist king, and with a second House based on merit rather than birth. Then comes the crown. Cromwell is often painted as dithering, but this account says he refused it within three days. The pressure keeps coming. Supporters keep working on him, the details are rewritten, and the argument starts again. Cromwell gives the same answer. He takes the new settlement, but will not become King. The army counts here too. Lambert brings officers to Cromwell and urges rejection, though the host will not let the army become the whole explanation. The close lands this as the end of a long run on Cromwell, the Republic, culture, science, and what the revolution left behind.

As heard by us

A brisk constitutional run through the Protectorate’s pressure points and Cromwell’s central role.

It frames the Protectorate as a system under strain, not a tidy settlement. Royalists and disappointed Levellers are pulled into the opposition to Cromwell, the Major Generals are shown reaching the end of the road, and the Humble Petition and Advice comes across as an effort to…

Read the full review in PlayNext →

Why you'd press play

Cromwell, plots, and a constitution built around one man.

Read the full recommendation in PlayNext →

Listen to the show on

Apple Podcasts Spotify

Play clips from this episode More from The History of England