Episode 5: The Expectations vs. the Realities of Freshman Year

July 6, 2020·47 min·3 clips

Two high schoolers argue that body types have become trends, and the 'average' body is the one nobody talks about.

Hosts Erica and Emily open by framing this as the fifth and final episode of their freshman year segment, part of a larger series covering all four years of high school. They begin by debunking the High School Musical fantasy, noting that high school requires real academic responsibility even if teachers in ninth grade tend to be more supportive than students fear. Emily recalls being warned by middle school teachers that high school would demand self-motivation, but found the transition less harsh than expected, while noting that teacher strictness increased noticeably by junior year. The hosts discuss the social intimidation of being surrounded by students up to three years older, with Emily admitting she felt mature as a freshman but now recognizes how young she actually was. They describe the social pressure of being an underclassman and how they both glorified upperclassmen, with Erica noting she later became friends with older students in tenth grade who accelerated her sense of maturity. The conversation turns to Link Crew, a structured freshman orientation program at their school where junior and senior volunteers guide incoming students around campus, answer questions, and serve as year-round support contacts. Both hosts participated as freshmen and later as Link Crew leaders, and they describe the experience of being on both sides as meaningful. They recommend that students at schools without such programs advocate for one through student government or National Honor Society. On the topic of social cliques, Erica and Emily argue that the movie stereotype of rigid, exclusive groups does not reflect reality, pointing to students they know who participate in athletics, TSA, band, and student government simultaneously. Body image is addressed next, with both hosts acknowledging that unrealistic standards affect boys and girls equally, and Erica sharing that she gained weight during puberty in eighth and ninth grade before making peace with her body. They criticize the way ideal body types shift like trends in society, calling it unfair that physical attributes can be celebrated one year and dismissed the next. They emphasize that exercise and health choices should be driven by personal well-being rather than social media standards or beauty trends. The hosts then move into bullying, with Erica describing two years on junior varsity basketball where a teammate competing for the same position made critical comments that worsened her mental block and led to her losing her starting spot. She explains that her friends reported the situation to coaches, which resolved the toxic dynamic and allowed her to regain her position and win most improved player on varsity. Emily adds that involvement in any visible activity, including soccer, exposes students to public criticism that can feel like bullying, and both agree that reaching out to a trusted adult is essential when criticism becomes repetitive. The hosts discuss the broader lesson that discomfort in high school can produce growth, and that freshman year is a formative time for discovering strengths, weaknesses, and identity. Erica reflects that she was quiet and isolated her freshman year before finding her voice and her close friends in sophomore year. The episode closes with a candid warning about upperclassmen taking advantage of freshmen, particularly in romantic contexts, noting that new students have no way of knowing an older student's reputation or intentions. They reference a previous guest named Sabrina as an example of someone who was not surrounded by good influences early on. Both hosts encourage freshmen to trust their intuition, avoid stooping to the level of those who mistreat them, and remember that upperclassmen who cause problems will eventually leave.

As heard by us

A sharp freshman-year look at pressure, body image, and the gap between expectation and reality.

The Gray Area closes out its freshman-year run by treating high school as a place where expectations get messy fast. Erica and Emily keep returning to body image, puberty, and the gap between what middle school promises and what high school actually feels like.

Read the full review in PlayNext →

Why you'd press play

Want a fast, honest reset on freshman-year expectations?

Read the full recommendation in PlayNext →

Listen to the show on

Apple Podcasts Spotify

Play clips from this episode More from The Gray Area