The Godfrey Audio Guide · Nicole Knudsen

Feed Drop: Who the F**k Killed My Sister

September 26, 2025·32 min·2 clips

Tracking data shows Eduardo and creepy scientist Lilith both drove to a deserted field at midnight, near where a body was stolen.

The episode opens with a cold open scene in which Quinn commandeers a stolen car, runs red lights, hands Leo a gun, and disappears into an abandoned asylum on what he later describes as her infamous third date ride-or-die test. The scene establishes Quinn's reckless, driven personality. At a diner, Quinn analyzes suspects while watching Eduardo's apartment building across the street. She dismisses Eduardo as too lazy and unsophisticated to be the serial killer, who has strangled three women resembling Kat and stolen their bodies from the morgue three separate times without detection. Quinn mentions she previously solved the murder of her fiancé Jonathan in 66 days, but notes that case was easier because the killer bragged online. She places the focus on the killer's method and skill level. Quinn retrieves a car tracker she planted under Eduardo's vehicle in daylight. Returning to her office building, she encounters Gregory, the husband of the first victim Naomi Barth, who arrives in an agitated state to report a fourth murder. The victim was a redhead, her nails painted the same red as previous victims, and her body was already stolen from Central University Hospital's morgue. Gregory breaks a lamp in distress and Quinn notes he is off his medication. Back in her office with Leo, Quinn cross-references tracking data from both Eduardo and Lilith's cars. Both independently drove to the same remote farm field between midnight and 2 AM the previous night. Additionally, Lilith's car was parked near the hospital morgue during the exact window the fourth victim's body disappeared. Quinn and Leo drive to the field, where they crash into a ditch after swerving for an animal. They search the property, finding a lone expensive high heel shoe in the wheat field. In the barn, they discover shackles chained to the wall and a large, relatively fresh bloodstain. As they attempt to leave, someone spots them.

As heard by us

A fast, sharp mystery where danger creeps in through the jokes.

Quinn opens the story one year after her sister's unsolved murder, and that detail gives the whole thing a hard edge from the start. The show leans into scene work: dirt under the nails, a scientist with jars of brains, and banter that keeps drifting toward danger.

Read the full review in PlayNext →

Why you'd press play

Press play if you want a murder mystery that starts already in motion.

Read the full recommendation in PlayNext →

Listen to the show on

Apple Podcasts Spotify

Play clips from this episode More from The Godfrey Audio Guide