The God and Gigs Show | A Podcast for Christian Creators · Allen C. Paul, Christian Creative Coach

The Hidden Danger of Selling Half a Million Books with David Gregory, Best-Selling Author

October 20, 2025·59 min·3 clips

A self-published 96-page book became a New York Times bestseller and a movie after he wanted garage copies.

Alan Paul opens by asking what happens when a creative dream finally lands. David Gregory answers from experience. He revisits Dinner with a Perfect Stranger and the reach it had. The book became a New York Times bestseller, sold more than half a million copies, and was adapted into a movie. That kind of success looks like the peak, but Gregory treats it more like a gift he never quite learned to manage. He says he still wants to write another book that reaches millions. He also admits the years since then have not brought the same kind of breakout. Since 2016, he has mostly self-published. That gives him freedom, and it also leaves him with publishers who are not especially interested. The conversation keeps coming back to calling, stewardship, and disappointment. Gregory is clear that he wrote the books, but not the machinery around them. He did not plan the publisher connection. He did not plan the movie call either. In his telling, those wins were gifts God dropped into his lap. That changes the way he talks about ambition. Success is not a trophy he can control. It is something entrusted to him for a season. Alan keeps pressing on what it means to carry that story as a Christian creator. He treats marketing as important, but not the center of the work. Gregory is blunt about feeling like the world's worst marketer. That honesty keeps the episode grounded. Instead of turning the breakout into a clean success story, the conversation sits with the harder second act. The episode lands on a quieter definition of impact, one heart at a time.

As heard by us

A candid look at the ache of a breakout success that never becomes a formula.

The episode follows David Gregory through the long tail of a breakout win: a bestselling book, a movie adaptation, and the quieter work of living after the peak.

Read the full review in PlayNext →

Why you'd press play

When your biggest win becomes the thing you cannot reproduce.

Read the full recommendation in PlayNext →

Listen to the show on

Apple Podcasts Spotify

Play clips from this episode More from The God and Gigs Show | A Podcast for Christian Creators