The Gaggle: An Arizona politics podcast · The Arizona Republic and azcentral.com

Where the Trump 2020 fake electors case stands in Arizona

January 7, 2026·17 min·1 clip
The Arizona Supreme Court could force Chris Mays to restart her fake electors case from scratch, a huge undertaking that has defense teams celebrating.
The episode opens by putting Arizona's fake-electors case inside a bigger cycle of political repetition. It starts with the 2020 pressure campaign on Arizona officials. Trump and his allies pushed the state to set aside certified results and present an alternate slate of electors. Arizona did not do that. Trump lost the state and Joe Biden won the White House. The story then jumps to 2022, when Democrat Chris Mays narrowly won the attorney general's race. Her office indicted the people tied to the alternate-elector effort. Most of those cases still have not gone to trial. That delay is one of the episode's central tensions. The conversation keeps circling back to what remains unresolved. One thread is a set of emails that one side says matters and the other side treats as basically irrelevant. The fight is a familiar legal standoff. The state says the messages are important. Lehman's team says they do not amount to much. The episode does not try to settle that dispute. Instead, it uses it to show how much is still being fought over behind the scenes. Another thread is the partial cleanup from earlier resolutions. Jenna Ellis agreed to have her charges dropped in exchange for testifying against co-defendants. Lorraine Pellegrino pleaded guilty in 2024 to reduced charges. She received a three-year probation sentence. Those outcomes narrow the case, but they do not close it. The episode also keeps an eye on timing. Mays is running for re-election. Trump is back in the White House. The case could still go to trial later this year. That overlap gives the legal story a political edge that is hard to miss. The conversation asks whether Mays really wanted this case still hanging over her office. The answer is clearly no. It also suggests that the long-running case may have helped her draw a line between herself and her Republican challenger. She has framed herself as someone defending democracy, and the episode notes that she has spent much of 2025 suing the Trump administration on other fronts too. The discussion then widens into public attention and political mood. Arizonans helped return Trump to the White House in 2024. That changes the symbolism of the case, even if it does not change the legal file. The episode handles that shift carefully. It does not say the case no longer matters. It says the public may be looking elsewhere while the legal work keeps grinding forward. The interview style stays practical. It asks what the emails mean, who is pointing fingers, and what the case might reveal once more of the record comes out. It also keeps the listener oriented around process: indictments, testimony, plea deals, trial timing, and campaign pressure. That structure is the point. The episode turns a national scandal into an Arizona-specific legal and political map. It asks where the case stands, who still has exposure, and why the calendar itself has become part of the story.

As heard by us

A careful look at Arizona's fake-electors case as law and politics still unfolding.

Arizona's fake-electors case is treated as a live piece of state politics, not a finished chapter in national drama. It follows where the indictments stand, notes that most defendants still have not gone to trial, and keeps the case anchored to a 2026 election year still shaped…

Read the full review in PlayNext →

Why you'd press play

If you want the Arizona fake-electors case explained without losing the plot, press play.

Read the full recommendation in PlayNext →
Listen to the show on