The Gaggle: An Arizona politics podcast · The Arizona Republic and azcentral.com

Two sides on deadly ICE actions and protests

January 28, 2026·44 min·4 clips
Erica Connell declares the American fascist party has taken over, calling it a constitutional crisis.
The episode begins with a content warning and a brief promotional mention before turning to the main discussion. It centers on the killing of an American citizen during federal immigration enforcement in Minneapolis. That death is treated as part of the wider national debate over the crackdown on illegal immigrants and the methods used to carry it out. The hosts bring in the concerns of Second Amendment advocates, who are not known for criticizing the Trump administration but are unsettled by the shooting. From there, the conversation moves to the protests that have grown around the enforcement surge. There is repeated pushback against the idea that protesters are being paid or staged by some outside force. The tone stays skeptical of that propaganda without getting overly dramatic. A long stretch of the discussion turns to how local police should respond if similar tensions rise in Phoenix or Tucson. The hosts ask what happens when federal authorities want local cooperation and city police have to decide how far to go. The 287(g) agreement comes up as part of that question. The argument is that these arrangements can turn into a power grab if they are not tied to clear civic limits. The conversation also leans on basic civics, separating federal, state, and local responsibilities. That structure matters because the episode is focused on what happens when federal pressure intensifies. The hosts use a stark comparison to make the point that states still matter as a governing layer. Instead, they are treated as the level that can still function if the center falters. That framing gives the episode a sober edge. It is a practical attempt to map the machinery of enforcement and resistance. Phoenix police are cited as an example of a department that understands its own legal boundaries. The episode keeps returning to the question of what local law enforcement should do when asked to carry out a mission that does not match state law. By the end, the piece has become less about one shooting than about the institutions that decide what comes next. That is the shape of the conversation throughout: a national controversy narrowed to local consequences, then examined from there.

As heard by us

An Arizona-centered look at federal immigration enforcement, protest, and the limits of local police power.

This episode centers on a deadly federal immigration-enforcement shooting and widens the lens to protests, firearms, and the role local police should play when federal pressure rises.

Read the full review in PlayNext →

Why you'd press play

You want the Arizona stakes behind a national immigration fight.

Read the full recommendation in PlayNext →
Listen to the show on