The Franchise

Super Mario Bros. (1993) | The Super Mario Bros. Movie (2023)

·1 hr 51 min·5 clips
Logan watched the hated 1993 Super Mario Bros. movie and found himself thinking, 'This is kind of good.'
Daniel Ehrenberg opens by putting two Mario movies on the table. Logan B. Adair has finally seen the live-action Super Mario Brothers. He expected a mess because that is the story he had always heard. Instead, he starts warming to it during the movie and likes it even more by the end. Daniel is delighted, since Rocky Morton and Annabelle Jankel's film is one of his all-time favorites. The argument turns to risk. The older film takes some, and the pair think that counts for a lot when video game movies keep pandering to their audience. The newer Mario movie gets the unpleasant comparison. Logan says he hated the first one, while Daniel says he almost dropped his rating from a two to a one on a second watch. The live-action movie earns its plumbing defense in the sewer. Mario and Luigi go looking for Daisy while trying to stop the bad guys. They end up fixing pipes until the bad guys arrive and bash them over the head. Mario's line about listening to pipes all his life becomes the episode's favorite evidence. Luigi's correction about the echo only makes the scene better for them. The conversation also turns Mario into a good boyfriend. He wants to take Daniella to WrestleMania IX in Vegas, which opens a detour into Yokozuna, Hulk Hogan, the outdoor setting, and Giant Gonzalez. The newer movie returns through its cast. Rosalina is linked to Brie Larson, Benny Safdie is discussed as Bowser Jr. or possibly baby Bowser, and Jack Black is said to be back. Louise Guzman and Issa Rae also enter the casting discussion, though the pair are not totally sure what some of it means. The episode wraps with a Patreon plug, Survivor 50 talk, Mamma Mia, and a final Mario sign-off.

As heard by us

A Mario franchise chat that gives sewer pipes a livelier defense than the newer movie.

The Franchise's Mario double feature turns into a small case for oddness as a virtue. Daniel Ehrenberg and Logan B. Adair make room for a fond reappraisal of the live-action Super Mario Bros., especially when the movie lingers on sewer pipes, physical knockabout, and Mario's…

Read the full review in PlayNext →

Why you'd press play

You get a fair hearing for the infamous live-action Mario, with the newer Mario era hovering like a coming storm.

Read the full recommendation in PlayNext →
Listen to the show on