The Forrager Podcast for Cottage Food Businesses · David Crabill

Alecia Ryan with Lee Cee Pie

·53 min·4 clips
She matched Rowan Inc.'s pink-and-green branding with three cookie flavors and a custom menu.
David Creeble speaks with Alicia Ryan, who runs Lisi Pie from Ardmore, Pennsylvania. She started the business in 2022 on a whim after finding a pie recipe she loved. The first version of the business was impulsive. She then stepped back for almost two years because life got in the way. When she restarted, she leaned on a stronger brand and a coffee shop partnership. That move helped her go from no orders to selling hundreds of cookies in a week. The conversation then turns to how she thinks about the menu. Pies are still central, but they are slow and attention-heavy. She says the hand pies are fully made by her from scratch, with no phyllo dough involved. Because they take so much time and she also has a full-time job, she releases them only in certain seasons. Those seasonal windows include spring around Mother's Day or Easter, and then Thanksgiving and Christmas. The episode also digs into the apple pie cookie that grew out of her original pie idea. That cookie uses three separate parts: an apple pie, an apple jam swirl, and pastry pieces cut into triangles for the top. She describes the work as labor-intensive, which makes the finished cookie feel like a small project in itself. The three-ounce specialty cookie sold for $6.50. She had originally imagined Lisi Pie as a one-product bakery with many flavors and fillings. Over time, she realized pies are special but too time-consuming to be the whole operation. Cookies gave her a faster way to expand the menu, and she is now moving into cakes as well. Even so, the pies remain the heart and soul of Lisi Pie.

As heard by us

A practical look at rebuilding a cottage bakery around what actually sells.

Alicia Ryan's story offers a practical look at how a cottage food business can pause, reset, and regain traction. She describes launching Lisi Pie on a whim after finding a pie recipe she loved, stepping away for almost two years because of life circumstances, then returning by…

Read the full review in PlayNext →

Why you'd press play

Hear how a cottage baker turns a pause, a partnership, and one pie into momentum without overcomplicating it.

Read the full recommendation in PlayNext →
Listen to the show on