The Fitness Business Podcast with Erin Dimond and Jordan Dugger · Erin Dimond and Jordan Dugger

EP | 717 - How To Get a Setter Into KPI and Filling Up Your Calendar With Calls

·21 min·1 clip
Erin's rule: don't start in the DMs; begin at the set-to-close KPI and work backwards to find the true constraint.
The conversation starts with a blunt point: an underperforming team member can burn through money, momentum, and patience fast. The hosts frame the issue as a starting-line problem, because if calls are not landing on the calendar and sales are not happening, there is not much else to diagnose yet. In that sense, the business works like a conveyor belt: when the front end breaks, everything downstream goes with it. They begin by asking whether the setter is pitching enough calls. If someone is pitching plenty of calls but not booking them, the next step is to look at the conversations, the scripts, the DM audits, and the coaching. The point is not to jump to conclusions. The point is to earn the right to go deeper. From there, they move down the funnel. If the pitching looks fine, they ask whether the setter is having enough qualified conversations each day. That means talking to people who are actually a fit, who have a problem the business solves, and who have a reason to care. If the person is talking to the wrong people, they can stay busy all day without producing anything useful. Then they go one step earlier and ask whether there are enough total conversations starting in the first place. Are they doing proactive outreach, engaging people, and creating enough starting points for the funnel to work? Or are they just waiting in the DMs for people to show up on their own? That distinction matters, because raw activity is not the same as progress. Only after those layers do they get to work minutes. That is the last metric, not the first. The episode argues that if every earlier checkpoint is healthy, how long someone worked matters a lot less than most managers think. The business should care about results before it cares about time spent sitting there. The episode also gets very direct about standards. If a manager has coached, clarified, and level-set, and the issue is still there, the question becomes whether the person can meet the standard or needs to move on. That is treated as a leadership decision, not a personal attack. The hosts keep coming back to the idea that you cannot stay stuck forever trying to rescue the same situation. At some point, you make a decision. Being patient is not the same as lowering standards, and repeating yourself only goes so far. There is also an explicit warning about resentment. When underperformance lingers, it starts to cost the business and the leader emotionally. The hosts treat that as a real operational problem, not just a bad mood. What makes the episode practical is the sequence. It gives managers a way to troubleshoot instead of spiraling into frustration. Start with pitch quality, move to qualified conversations, then total conversations started, and only then look at minutes worked. That order makes it easier to know whether the problem is training, effort, fit, or standards. The tone stays conversational and fast, but the logic is structured. The listener can hear the framework in real time, which makes it easy to reuse later. By the end, the message is simple: do not let a broken standard hide inside a fuzzy conversation about effort. Find the actual leak in the funnel and deal with it directly.

As heard by us

A clear funnel read for when a setter looks like the problem, but may only be the symptom.

The episode takes a setter who is not filling the calendar and refuses to stop at the easy blame. It moves through the funnel from conversations started to qualified conversations, then to pitch quality and minutes worked, which makes the problem easier to measure instead of…

Read the full review in PlayNext →

Why you'd press play

You need a tighter way to tell whether an underperforming setter is actually the bottleneck.

Read the full recommendation in PlayNext →
Listen to the show on