The FitMind Podcast: Mental Fitness, Neuroscience & Psychology · FitMind: Neuroscience, Meditation & Mental Fitness Training

#108: The Ethics of Meditation - Nicholas Van Dam, PhD

·1 hr 46 min·1 clip

Science didn't invent meditation traditions predating modern research centuries ago

The guest treats meditation as something with deep historical roots. He pushes back on the idea that scientists and academics should talk as if these practices were invented in the 1980s or 1990s. The conversation starts with translation. It asks how modern research can use contemporary language without flattening the worldview of the traditions it studies. He suggests that traditions offer maps of interior life. He also suggests that science has its own maps. The useful work may be in setting them beside each other. Those maps will not always line up. Even so, comparing them may help build newer maps that are a little bit more empirically grounded and better aligned with contemporary knowledge. The discussion then widens into meaning. He sees real room for meditation in a moment when many people are dealing with deficits in purpose and meaning. The host follows that thread toward ethics. The pair consider whether meditation should be treated as a private product or as part of community life. They worry about the way modern versions of meditation can be shaped to fit market expectations. That concern includes pressure to promise outcomes and package the practice as something to sell. He contrasts that with older traditions in which these practices were free and meant to be practiced within a community toward a greater good. The host notes that FitMind itself was once a paid app before its founder became a monk and turned it into a free NGO. That example makes the access question concrete. The episode closes by directing listeners to Google Contemplative Study Center, UniMelb, for more.

As heard by us

A careful look at meditation's ethics and at the tension between contemplative practice and modern packaging.

Meditation is treated here as both a question of method and a question of values. The discussion argues that modern research should make room for older traditions, while still finding language that can describe inner experience without stripping away what gives the practice its…

Read the full review in PlayNext →

Why you'd press play

You want the ethics behind meditation, not another wellness sales pitch.

Read the full recommendation in PlayNext →

Listen to the show on

Apple Podcasts Spotify

Play clips from this episode More from The FitMind Podcast: Mental Fitness, Neuroscience & Psychology