The Fantistics Fantasy Baseball Podcast · InsiderBaseball

March 19, 2025 - You Are Over-Drafting These Guys

·1 hr 22 min·2 clips

Luis Castillo is being drafted at the edge of SP1 and SP2, but the Draft Advisory Program has him in the middle of the 18th round.

The show opens with the familiar back-and-forth between the two hosts. One is content to let the other handle the logistics. They joke about schedules and about holding the Tout Wars auction discussion for a later episode. Chris Towers from CBS comes up as a recent conversation partner. The tone stays relaxed and easy throughout. The hosts then shift into the main fantasy baseball topic: players whose draft prices may be getting inflated by familiarity and exposure. The logic stays practical rather than dramatic. If a name is going early, the question is whether the production really supports that cost. They work through power output, at-bat totals, and how much volume a player can realistically get. One Mets hitter becomes the clearest example. The discussion notes that he has enough pop to matter. It also notes that his batting average and split performance leave real room for concern. The hosts look at who might take playing time away if the roster changes. Jeff McNeil’s absence opens the door, and Brett Beaty is mentioned as a possible factor. The conversation keeps circling back to the same tension: there is upside, but the floor is not stable. The player could still return enough power to justify the cost. He could also end up in a smaller role once the team gets healthy. The hosts keep qualifying the outlook as the evidence changes. That is the rhythm of the episode throughout. It starts with a casual question and ends with a fantasy decision. The final advice is cautious: do not chase the name too hard, and stay a little stingy on the draft price.

As heard by us

A steady look at draft-day inflation, built on playing-time doubt and market sense.

The episode takes a plainspoken look at the problem of paying too much for familiar fantasy baseball names. It keeps coming back to playing time, split data, and lineup pressure, which makes the argument feel grounded instead of theoretical.

Read the full review in PlayNext →

Why you'd press play

Need a sanity check before you pay up for the wrong Mets bat?

Read the full recommendation in PlayNext →

Listen to the show on

Apple Podcasts Spotify

Play clips from this episode More from The Fantistics Fantasy Baseball Podcast