The Falcon · Dougall & Bennett

The Falcon - The Case Of The King Of Hearts

April 7, 2026·27 min·2 clips

The Falcon accuses bellhop Billy Matthews of murdering Johnny King in front of Grace Burton and Sergeant Corbett, pivoting on the missing $18,000 as the motive.

Johnny King has a talent. He calls himself a pretty fair-looking boy, which is his tidy way of saying trouble pays when he is the one selling it. Grace wants out fast. Vic has gone to Mike Waring, so she runs to Johnny before the game closes in. Johnny is already packing. He tells Grace the shop is moving, with plenty of smooth talk and no apology, because loyalty is not really part of his act. Grace starts talking murder. Johnny treats it like noise, just another desperate threat from someone who mistook him for a future. Billy Matthews keeps drifting nearby. A bellboy can pass through doors, catch scraps, and look harmless while everyone watches the sharper suits. That is the whole trick. When Billy learns Johnny is checking out, he sees his chance and walks straight into the room. The hotel gives him cover. Nobody notices a bellboy, which makes him just about the most dangerous man there. Johnny gets killed for it. The strange figure in the raincoat is smoke, a neat little story Billy uses to pull eyes away. The money tells the better story. Billy has eighteen grand tucked away, five more shaken out of Mrs. Burton, and still nicks the wrong man for twenty-five bucks. Mike puts it together. One small inconsistency, one too helpful hotel boy, and the case stops looking mysterious and starts looking cheap. The ending stays dry. The Sergeant nearly forgives the murder, then admits the shot at Mike bothers him only because Billy missed.

As heard by us

This one moves with a clipped, no-nonsense pace.

This one moves with a clipped, no-nonsense pace. Billy Matthews looks harmless at first, but he is carrying too many secrets and too much cash, and the pressure builds once the money, Mrs. Burton, and room 912 enter the picture.

Read the full review in PlayNext →

Why you'd press play

You want a hotel-room scam where the bellboy is the one you should not trust.

Read the full recommendation in PlayNext →

Listen to the show on

Apple Podcasts Spotify

Play clips from this episode More from The Falcon