The Eric Metaxas Show

On Myth as a Vehicle for Truth A Dialogues Conversation with Holly Ordway & Louis Markos

·42 min·4 clips
In C.S. Lewis's novel, a non-religious character rejects trampling a crucifix, showing imagination's power to grasp truth before reason.
The host opens with travel and conference news from Tennessee. He explains that he is speaking at the Christianity and Culture Conference at World Outreach Church after being invited by Pastor Alan Jackson, in a slot originally meant for Charlie Kirk. From there, the conversation turns to the strange, powerful way stories can carry truth into the imagination. The discussion centers on Lewis's That Hideous Strength. Its character Mark is facing a direct attack on the small amount of faith he may possess. The forces around him want him to reject objective morality and become amoral. The imagery grows darker as demonic horses enter the picture. Mark's final test involves trampling a crucifix. He has not been raised religious, so the object does not come to him with a ready-made theological meaning. He sees the figure on the crucifix as an embodiment of the straight and normal thing being threatened by twisted forces. The figure is helpless, and that helplessness stirs an instinctive revolt. Mark chooses to stand with the humiliated wooden figure even if that means losing. That decision becomes his real conversion moment. He does not arrive there through a completed abstract argument about objective morality. His imagination grasps what the image means before his intellect has put everything in order. The discussion draws that point toward the work of persuasion. Arguments can pass right over listeners when the imagination has no meaningful image to hold. The conversation then moves to Tolkien and the Augustinian understanding of evil as spoiled goodness. It pushes against a simplistic reading of The Lord of the Rings as only a flat contest between bad guys and good guys, with Sauron, the Dark Tower, Mount Doom, and Saruman helping complicate that easy division.

As heard by us

A crucifix, a moral choice, and the imagination's role in recognizing truth.

Myth becomes a pressure test for moral perception here, as the conversation links imaginative storytelling to the possibility of objective morality. Its center is That Hideous Strength, especially Mark's refusal to trample a crucifix despite not being religious.

Read the full review in PlayNext →

Why you'd press play

Want a story to test your moral instincts before your intellect catches up?

Read the full recommendation in PlayNext →
Listen to the show on