“America is NOT OUR ENEMY”–Poilievre NUKES Carney’s Narrative with One Sentence

·15 min·1 clip

Pierre Poilievre declares the American people are not Canada's adversaries, directly countering Mark Carney's fear-based messaging.

The episode opens with host Josh introducing the day's main topic: Pierre Poilievre's speech on Canada-US relations. Josh positions the speech as a potential source of 'hopium' for those wanting a pragmatic, adult approach to the relationship, contrasting it with fear-mongering. The first story covered is Poilievre's upcoming international trip to the UK and Germany as opposition leader, framed as an effort to appear prime ministerial. The core analysis then delves into Poilievre's speech. Josh highlights how Poilievre began by reminding Canadians of the country's historical achievements, like building the railway and CN Tower, to advocate for a focus on what Canada can control. The central clip discussed is Poilievre's assertion that the American people are not Canada's adversaries, directly countering narratives from figures like Mark Carney. Poilievre quoted President Kennedy on the bonds between the two nations. The most headline-grabbing moment was Poilievre's line that Canada should not declare a permanent rupture with the US for a strategic partnership with Beijing, which Josh notes calls out Mark Carney's rhetoric. Poilievre also listed Chinese government actions like kidnapping citizens and pushing fentanyl. In a Q&A, when asked why he was calm despite Canadian anger, Poilievre responded pragmatically, focusing on what Canada can control. Josh praises this as steady leadership. The speech also included policy proposals like an all-party committee for upcoming CUSMA negotiations and a strategic mineral reserve to use as a bargaining chip for tariff-free access to the US. Josh concludes by noting the speech just ended, and he will have more thoughts in a future livestream.

As heard by us

A close read of Poilievre's pragmatic pitch for Canada-US ties amid fear-based political messaging.

The Elevate Report reads Pierre Poilievre's Economic Club of Canada speech as a test of whether Canadian politics can discuss the United States without turning trade into fear messaging.

Read the full review in PlayNext →

Why you'd press play

Want to hear Poilievre make the case that American workers are not Canada's enemy?

Read the full recommendation in PlayNext →

Listen to the show on

Apple Podcasts Spotify

Play clips from this episode More from The Elevate Report