The Documentary Podcast · BBC World Service

The women of IS: Part two

·30 min·2 clips

A Yazidi survivor in Syria refuses to go home because her family told her: 'You can come back, but you cannot bring your children back — she is an ISIS daughter.'

1. The Documentary Podcast episode “The women of IS: Part two” examines how states handle women and children trapped in IS detention camps in Syria. 2. Presenter Krasivanova Twig is joined by BBC Monitoring and regional experts including Nicole Jigsaw, Mina Al-Lami, Bryn Windsor, Claire Denning, Mohamed Al-Jumaili, Barry Marston, and Ziyar Gol, who explain media narratives and repatriation policy. 3. The episode asks whether countries see these detainees as victims, perpetrators, or both, and how that choice affects repatriation. 4. Mina Al-Lami says IS declared a “so-called caliphate” in 2014 and drew people from “some 60 nations” with religious, political, and personal appeals. 5. The transcript highlights recruiters targeting young girls from Western Europe with promises of romance, using the cases of Shamima Begum, Amira Abbas, and Khadiza Sultana. 6. Barry Marston describes many women’s testimony as a claim that husbands forced them to travel, blackmailed them with children, or deceived them about going to Turkey. 7. The episode stresses that courts in Europe struggle to separate “victims and those who are perpetrators” when the crimes involved are among the most serious in modern times. 8. Bryn Windsor explains that Central Asian states saw Islam as a security issue after the Soviet Union and imposed limits on religious education, beard length, and niqab use. 9. He says around 5,000 Central Asian nationals went to Syria, with large numbers from Uzbekistan and a disproportionate share from Tajikistan. 10. The transcript connects Tajik recruitment to poverty, migrant labor in Russia and Turkey, and the appeal of IS Khorasan Province propaganda in Tajik and Uzbek. 11. The episode says Central Asian governments reversed their narrative after Islamic State fell in 2019, rebranding returnees from “traitors” to vulnerable citizens. 12. Kazakhstan’s Operation Rebirth, also called JUSAN, repatriated about 750 citizens, mostly women and children, after security officials identified them in Syrian camps. 13. Kyrgyzstan presents repatriation as both humanitarian and patriotic, with one official saying “our kind of Islam is not radical.” 14. The episode says the Central Asian program became a “model” commended by the UN and that about 2,200 Central Asians were repatriated in total. 15. Claire Denning explains that about 1,000 Russian women, 1,000 Russian minors, and more than 5,000 Russian men ended up in IS-held territory, mostly from the North Caucasus. 16. She links Russian repatriation to a 2017 RT documentary, Ramzan Kadyrov’s support, and later warnings from FSB chief Bortnikov that linked women posed a threat. 17. The tone is explanatory and policy-focused, with long quoted passages from experts and detainees rather than a fast-paced debate format. 18. Testimony from a woman in Raqqa, a Yazidi survivor near Qamishli, and officials from Kazakhstan and Kyrgyzstan gives the episode a documentary, reportorial style. 19. Best for listeners interested in Syria, repatriation policy, and IS detention camps. 20. Skip it if you want a short, plot-driven episode with no policy detail.

As heard by us

IS detention camps, return, refusal, and the politics of repatriation.

This episode follows residents of IS detention camps in Syria and treats their situation as a story shaped by return, refusal, and uncertainty.

Read the full review in PlayNext →

Why you'd press play

If you want the IS detention-camp repatriation fight, start here.

Read the full recommendation in PlayNext →

Listen to the show on

Apple Podcasts Spotify

Play clips from this episode More from The Documentary Podcast