The Documentary Filmmaker Podcast · Sue Collins

How to direct a documentary film with guest Mike Hill, Impact Documentary Filmmaker Ep96

·23 min·1 clip
Mike Hill says you should use index cards, wall layouts, and rushes to find the film’s structure.
Sue Collins welcomes her partner and co-producer, director Mike Hill. She frames the discussion around how he directs documentaries and how he thinks about making films that matter without making the work feel impossible to sustain. Mike says there is no single right way to make a film. He explains that documentary directing starts with organizing thoughts, then organizing an argument, and then testing that structure against the material that has actually been captured. Some pieces are obvious from the start. He gives the example of a participant whose footage clearly belongs in the film because it is already powerful, while other scenes stay uncertain until the larger shape comes into view. The wall matters. He recommends writing index cards for conceptual ideas, emotional beats, and the practical building blocks of the story, then moving them around until the flow makes sense to both the director and the editor. Rushes become the real work. As he watches the material, he treats the process like prospecting, looking for the gold in every reel and noting strong moments on cards so they can be placed where they do the most work in the film. The film gets built piece by piece. He keeps coming back to the idea that structure is something you discover by staying close to the footage, not something you force onto it before the footage has shown you what it can do. That patience is the point. The conversation stays grounded, with the practical reminder that the editor needs a shared map and that the organizing work is what helps both people see the same shape. There is also a promotional detour. The show pauses to point listeners toward Moonshine Communications Academy and the newsletter, with a warning-style read that sits beside the craft discussion instead of taking it over. The tone stays generous. Even when the work sounds difficult, expensive, overwhelming, or unglamorous, the advice keeps circling back to the same habits: collect evidence, sort the cards, trust the footage, and keep refining the argument. It closes with support. The episode wraps by inviting listeners to sign up for the weekly Moonshine email and receive a bonus ebook along with ongoing resources for making films that matter.

As heard by us

A practical look at how documentary material gets organized into a film that can actually be cut.

The piece treats Mike Hill’s directing process as a disciplined bit of work: gather the material, jot the cards, pin the ideas up, and keep reshaping the flow until the argument holds together. It is most useful when it stays grounded in process.

Read the full review in PlayNext →

Why you'd press play

You need a patient way to sort messy material into a film that makes sense.

Read the full recommendation in PlayNext →
Listen to the show on