The Dershow

Can Iran be negotiated to give up nuclear arsenal without bombing them?

·31 min·3 clips
Alan Dershowitz confronts a headline claiming Trump said Nazis treated Jewish prisoners with love.
The host begins with a headline. He says he has never been angrier at a magazine or newspaper headline. The headline attributes to Trump a claim that Nazis treated Jewish prisoners with love. The host treats that as a serious accusation, not just sloppy phrasing. The discussion then shifts to Iran. Trump is described as preferring a non-military solution to Iran's desire for a nuclear arsenal. The host says Iran is fairly close to obtaining one. He rejects Iran's previous denials of that goal. He argues that the country's leaders used religion to hide their intentions. The example is a fatwa from Iran's grand leader declaring nuclear weapons contrary to Islamic law. The host calls the fatwa a fake and a total cover. He points to Israeli spies finding a cache of hidden material. For him, that discovery proves Iran was developing nuclear weapons while denying it. The argument then turns to Rafsanjani. The host describes him as a former liberal head of Iran and as more pro-American and less anti-Semitic. Rafsanjani's stated scenario begins with Iran building a nuclear bomb and attacking Tel Aviv. The host repeats the claim that Israel could answer with atomic bombs against Tehran. He is careful to say he is not sure that part is true. The larger point is still stark: a nuclear exchange would mean catastrophic deaths in both societies. The argument treats Iran's nuclear ambitions as a danger that any non-military strategy has to face directly.

As heard by us

A fierce case for seeing diplomacy with Iran as a survival question, not just a policy debate.

The episode treats diplomacy less as a policy preference than as a question pressed up against annihilation. It begins with the host's anger over a New Republic headline about Trump and Nazi treatment of Jewish prisoners, then moves into Trump's stated preference for a…

Read the full review in PlayNext →

Why you'd press play

Want a furious argument about whether Iran can be kept from a nuclear arsenal without military action?

Read the full recommendation in PlayNext →
Listen to the show on